The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink Aboutpacketpreservation20160816 1 of 1 EVANSTON PRESERVATION COMMISSION Tuesday, August 16, 2016, 7:00 P.M. Lorraine H. Morton Civic Center, 2100 Ridge Avenue, Room 2404 AGENDA 1. CALL TO ORDER / DECLARATION OF QUORUM 2. OLD BUSINESS A. 917 Edgemere Court (LSHD) – Elliot Flaws, applicant. Construction of a new 2-story, brick and stucco single-family residence with an attached 1-story, 3-car garage in front. Applicable standards: [Construction] 1- 13, and 16 [Per Applicant’s request staff recommends continuance to September 20, 2016] B. 703 Forest Avenue (L/LSHD) – Preston Fawcett, applicant. 2 story frame addition - with screen porch with roof top deck and reworked existing decks. Applicable standards: [Alteration] 1-5 and 7-10; [Construction] 1- 16, [Demolition] 1-5. [Per Applicant’s request staff recommends continuance to September 20, 2016] 3. NEW BUSINESS A. 1030 Lake Shore Blvd (LSHD) – Alterations to east front elevation, including windows and adding entry foyer. Add stairs to existing wood deck, remove a door and three windows at rear west elevation, replace glass block with aluminum clad windows on north side elevation, and remove glass block, infill with brick and install aluminum clad window. Applicable standards: [Alteration] 1-7, 9 and 10; [Construction] 1- 15 4. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES of July 19, 2016. 5. COMMITTEE REPORTS (Working Groups) A. Preservation Ordinance Review Subcommittee - Update. 6. VOLUNTEER REPORTS A. Design Guidelines Volunteers - Update Order & Agenda Items are subject to change. Information about the Preservation Commission is available at: http://www.cityofevanston.org/government/boards-commissions/preservation-commission/index.php. Questions can be directed to Carlos Ruiz at 847-448-8687 or at cruiz@cityofevanston.org The city is committed to ensuring accessibility for all citizens; If an accommodation is needed to participate in this meeting, please contact the Planning and Zoning Division at (847 -448-8687) 48 hours in advance so that arrangements can be made for the accommodation if possible. Español - La ciudad de Evanston tiene la obligación de hacer accesibles todas las reuniones públicas a las personas minusválidas o a quienes no hablan inglés. Si usted necesita ayuda, favor contacte a Carlos D. Ruiz de la Oficina de Planificación y Zonificación llamando al (847/448-8687) o cruiz@cityofevanston.org con 48 horas de anticipación para acomodar su pedido en lo posible. 2 of 2 7. STAFF REPORTS 8. DISCUSSION (No vote will be taken) 9. ADJOURNMENT Next Meeting: TUESDAY, September 20, 2016 at 7:00 P.M. 3. NEW BUSINESS A. 1030 Lake Shore Blvd (LSHD) – Alterations to east front elevation, including windows and adding entry foyer. Add stairs to existing wood deck, remove a door and three windows at rear west elevation, replace glass block with aluminum clad windows on north side elevation, and remove glass block, infill with brick and install aluminum clad window. Applicable standards: [Alteration] 1-7, 9 and 10; [Construction] 1- 15 !" # $%& !"#$ % "& '( )" * +)" ,- )" .# / !" # $%& 01+ #%234 !"#" 5+%6 7 % 8 $%" $"& ' -% 9 %-+/%&% 8 ()$($ %"$"& +/:+ %% 9 - -+/8 ' + % % * 9 7;(- - ;;(6 7< = :% : % 3;% !#+#,#+ "+ -.!"/# +0- ++" -" " ".!"#"1#, *%7% 3 ++" " " 0" 22″ 023″ 4,. ++1> -*4" # (' # %/# 5#. 1&>0+++# - 0 - -0 0 . %% (%% &+% % "+# ". "",#, , 1+ 1# ' '16' 17.( "18299 #1:8921 1;<9892. "#," 29,# " # . ! ++"1> * -4 " #('. " " # ,+ -+)" +*..11+#1 1+ " 01".. ( : 8% % :"&++""# # + +--8=9++#,)"*0"+. !# #,#, ,+#,+> . ++" "0".6 7 %&%,+ ++,+ ,#, +> ". %%#4*?@3@@?A?<?3 "#4B"+ . % ; ;( - - 1030 Lake Shore Blvd. Rob and Gail Bush 1030 Lake Shore Blvd. Studio Talo Architecture 1234 Sherman Ave. #202 Evanston IL 60202 847.733.7300 thomas@studiotalo.comEvanstonIL 60202 x To Be Determined x 312.604.9105 rbush@ancelglink.com 9 % - + % :( 7: +:&%&+; & 7- ++ : +% % 7 '-+/%-+/%%+% + % !> ; # <3% =&%&% 17 %%? #" > '! " % C , "- % D -D - '' "- E( + A+-% E( F ;# C# * " % %"EC "- % E( "-% E( 0#" -/#-" ( & "- " " "#"# " #"# - +" x x x x x x x x x x x x x x Chain link gate to replace chain link fence on side. x x x xxx Fiber cement lap siding 8" The proposal includes improvements to address functional and aesthetic challenges in a way that is compatible with the scale, materials and character of the mid-century modern home. Work on the front includes improving the unsafe balcony, replacing 1970’s arched windows with rectangular doors/windows and adding a foyer under the balcony. stone patio at the entry and stone walkway will extend from the front door to the sidewalk to replace a circuitous concrete path. Sod will replace the front drive. Work on the sides consists of replacing glass block windows with fixed vision glass windows in the same openings. Work on the rear includes adding a wood stair from an existing second floor wood deck down to grade, changing an existing concrete patio to stone and removing rear first floor windows. Fiber cement lap siding to match the existing will clad the wall filling in where window is removed. luminum clad wood doors and windows to match existing. ' *-+/%!>@%A-+/%%+% !> 7 !> 7 !> 7 B< +C +@%%+ 7@% D %D (D#; G"> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH ## #""> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH "#""::7 HHHHHHHHHHHHHH D /&: HHHHHHHHHHHHHH ## D ::3/ $ (D 1( HHHHHH"(1! HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHG" > HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH" 7@%# " D 3@%> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH D D (3;(@% ! > # " ( G" > HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 1 (" '#,7## -+ @%> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH G"> HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH #""1 (@% > HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD ## D<3( +@%< % < ><"#2!>% + " > HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH & ## C 4 @ > HHHHHHHHHHHHHHH0 !# # , % )7 EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE " 3 ( ) & !" #$%&* !" #$%& x x x x Fiber cement lap siding and trim x x Membrane (mod. bitumen) x x Proposed scupper for small roof area over entry x x x x Fiber cement lap siding and trimxx x x "Wood-look" fiberglass glass patio x Fixed and awningx x Glass block x clad/wood int.x x x x x deck at reax entry x entry and rear patio and rear patio Thomas Ahleman 7.19.16 x ## EE EE | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 BUSH RESIDENCE 1030 LAKE SHORE BLVD. EVANSTON, IL 60202 07.19.16 CITY OF EVANSTON PRESERVATION COMMISSION REVIEW LOT LINE PUBLIC WALK LAKE SHORE BLVD. AL L E Y EXISTING CHAIN LINK FENCE 164.41' 60 . 0 0 ' 168.68' 60.3 0' REQ. REAR SETBACK 30.00' REQ. FRONT SETBACK 27.00' EXISTING FRONT SETBACK 40.21' SI D E S E T B A C K 5. 0 0 ' R E Q . SIDE SETBACK 5.00' REQ. SETBACK 6.04' EX. SIDE SETBACK 5.96' EX. SIDE EX. REAR SETBACK 54.52' A B C D E F G H | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR1.0BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/16" = 1'-0"1 SITE PLAN- EXISTING SITE KEYNOTES A EXISTING STRUCTURE A1 ENTRY ADDITION A2 FRONT PORCH W/ BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE PAVERS B EXISTING REAR CONCRETE DRIVE C EXISTING REAR CONCRETE PATIO C1 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE PATIO D EXISTING SOUTH WALKWAY D1 SOD TO REPLACE EXISTING WALKWAY E EXISTING CONCRETE FRONT DRIVE E1 SOD TO REPLACE EXISTING FRONT DRIVE F EXISTING CONCRETE NORTH PATHWAY F1 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE WALK F2 GRAVEL BED G EXISTING CONCRETE ENTRY WALK G1 FRONT CONCRETE WALK G2 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE FRONT STEP H EXISTING GRAVEL BED H1 EXTENSION TO EXISTING GRAVEL BED LOT LINE PUBLIC WALK LAKE SHORE BLVD. ALLEY PROPOSED WOOD STAIR TO EXISTING DECK EXISTING CHAIN LINK FENCE NEW GATE AT EXISTING FENCE REMOVE GATE AND FILL IN W/ NEW FENCE (NO CHANGE) 164.41' 60.00' 168.68' 60.3 0' REQ. REAR SETBACK 30.00' REQ. FRONT SETBACK 27.00' PROPOSED FRONT SETBACK 40.21' SIDE SETBACK 5.00' REQ. SIDE SETBACK 5.00' REQ. SETBACK 6.04' SIDE SETBACK 5.96' SIDE PROPOSED REAR SETBACK 54.52' (NO CHANGE) (NO CHANGE) (NO CHANGE) A B C1 D1 E1 F1 G1 H H1 F2 A1 A2 G2 2' - 6" 6' - 1" 52' - 4 1/2"6' - 6" 21' - 1" 6' - 6" 22' - 5 1/2" | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR1.1BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/16" = 1'-0"1 SITE PLAN- PROPOSED SITE KEYNOTES A EXISTING STRUCTURE A1 ENTRY ADDITION A2 FRONT PORCH W/ BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE PAVERS B EXISTING REAR CONCRETE DRIVE C EXISTING REAR CONCRETE PATIO C1 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE PATIO D EXISTING SOUTH WALKWAY D1 SOD TO REPLACE EXISTING WALKWAY E EXISTING CONCRETE FRONT DRIVE E1 SOD TO REPLACE EXISTING FRONT DRIVE F EXISTING CONCRETE NORTH PATHWAY F1 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE WALK F2 GRAVEL BED G EXISTING CONCRETE ENTRY WALK G1 FRONT CONCRETE WALK G2 BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE FRONT STEP H EXISTING GRAVEL BED H1 EXTENSION TO EXISTING GRAVEL BED | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.0BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 NE PERSPECTIVE- EXISTING | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.1BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 NE PERSPECTIVE- PROPOSED | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.2BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 SE PERSPECTIVE- EXISTING | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.3BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 SE PERSPECTIVE- PROPOSED | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.4BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 NW PERSPECTIVE- EXISTING | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR2.5BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1 NW PERSPECTIVE- PROPOSED ADDITION ENTRY T/ ROOF 20' - 8" 18 19 20 21 22 23 22 24 25 26 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 11 3 2 6 4 13 | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR3.0BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/8" = 1'-0"3 EAST ELEVATION- PROPOSED 2 EAST ELEVATION- ORIGINAL DRAWINGS 1/8" = 1'-0"1 EAST ELEVATION- EXISTING *FOR REFERENCE ONLY MATERIAL KEYNOTES 20 CLEAR GLASS AND STEEL GUARDRAIL 21 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS LAP SIDING TO MATCH REAR ADDITION 22 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS TRIM TO MATCH WINDOW CLADDING 23 18" GLASS CANOPY 24 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD DOOR AND WINDOW 25 NEW BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 26 STEP LIGHT 27 NEW CEDAR STAIR AND LANDING TO MATCH EXISTING DECK 28 ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW TO MATCH EXISTING 29 FILL IN OPENING W/ BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 30 NEW PAINTED FIBERGLASS EXTERIOR DOOR 31 NEW CHAINLINK GATE AT EXISTING FENCE 32 REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 33 NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW AND LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING W/ BRICK INFILL BELOW TO MATCH EXISTING 34 NEW LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING MATERIAL KEYNOTES 1 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 2 EXISTING PAINTED T & G WOOD SOFFIT 3 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS PANEL 4 EXISTING ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 5 EXISTING LIMESTONE SILL 6 EXISTING BRICK 7 EXISTING FRONT DOOR 8 EXISTING SHRUBS 9 EXISTING PAINTED ALUMINUM WRAPPED TRIM 10 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 11 EXISTING CEDAR T & G SOFFIT 12 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS SIDING 13 EXISTING LIMESTONE WINDOW SURROUND 14 EXISTING CHAINLINK FENCE 15 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD PANEL DOOR 16 EXISTING WOOD FRAMED DECK AND RAILING 17 EXISTING GLASS BLOCK WINDOW 18 RECESSED LIGHTING IN NEW BEADBOARD SOFFIT TO MATCH GARAGE OVERHANG. 19 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD OPERABLE WINDOW WALL 1 14 4 16 6 5 33 1 15 14 6 12 3 4 1 DECK EXISTING STAIR NEW T/ ROOF 20' - 8" 27 28 29 21 30 31 | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR3.1BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/8" = 1'-0"1 EXISTING WEST ELEVATION 1/8" = 1'-0"2 PROPOSED WEST ELEVATION MATERIAL KEYNOTES 1 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 2 EXISTING PAINTED T & G WOOD SOFFIT 3 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS PANEL 4 EXISTING ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 5 EXISTING LIMESTONE SILL 6 EXISTING BRICK 7 EXISTING FRONT DOOR 8 EXISTING SHRUBS 9 EXISTING PAINTED ALUMINUM WRAPPED TRIM 10 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 11 EXISTING CEDAR T & G SOFFIT 12 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS SIDING 13 EXISTING LIMESTONE WINDOW SURROUND 14 EXISTING CHAINLINK FENCE 15 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD PANEL DOOR 16 EXISTING WOOD FRAMED DECK AND RAILING 17 EXISTING GLASS BLOCK WINDOW 18 RECESSED LIGHTING IN NEW BEADBOARD SOFFIT TO MATCH GARAGE OVERHANG. 19 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD OPERABLE WINDOW WALL 20 CLEAR GLASS AND STEEL GUARDRAIL 21 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS LAP SIDING TO MATCH REAR ADDITION 22 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS TRIM TO MATCH WINDOW CLADDING 23 18" GLASS CANOPY 24 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD DOOR AND WINDOW 25 NEW BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 26 STEP LIGHT 27 NEW CEDAR STAIR AND LANDING TO MATCH EXISTING DECK 28 ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW TO MATCH EXISTING 29 FILL IN OPENING W/ BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 30 NEW PAINTED FIBERGLASS EXTERIOR DOOR 31 NEW CHAINLINK GATE AT EXISTING FENCE 32 REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 33 NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW AND LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING W/ BRICK INFILL BELOW TO MATCH EXISTING 34 NEW LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING 1 6 17 5 12 3 16 14 T/ ROOF 20' - 8" 32 27 | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR3.2BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/8" = 1'-0"1 NORTH ELEVATION- EXISTING 1/8" = 1'-0"2 NORTH ELEVATION- PROPOSED MATERIAL KEYNOTES 1 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 2 EXISTING PAINTED T & G WOOD SOFFIT 3 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS PANEL 4 EXISTING ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 5 EXISTING LIMESTONE SILL 6 EXISTING BRICK 7 EXISTING FRONT DOOR 8 EXISTING SHRUBS 9 EXISTING PAINTED ALUMINUM WRAPPED TRIM 10 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 11 EXISTING CEDAR T & G SOFFIT 12 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS SIDING 13 EXISTING LIMESTONE WINDOW SURROUND 14 EXISTING CHAINLINK FENCE 15 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD PANEL DOOR 16 EXISTING WOOD FRAMED DECK AND RAILING 17 EXISTING GLASS BLOCK WINDOW 18 RECESSED LIGHTING IN NEW BEADBOARD SOFFIT TO MATCH GARAGE OVERHANG. 19 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD OPERABLE WINDOW WALL 20 CLEAR GLASS AND STEEL GUARDRAIL 21 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS LAP SIDING TO MATCH REAR ADDITION 22 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS TRIM TO MATCH WINDOW CLADDING 23 18" GLASS CANOPY 24 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD DOOR AND WINDOW 25 NEW BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 26 STEP LIGHT 27 NEW CEDAR STAIR AND LANDING TO MATCH EXISTING DECK 28 ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW TO MATCH EXISTING 29 FILL IN OPENING W/ BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 30 NEW PAINTED FIBERGLASS EXTERIOR DOOR 31 NEW CHAINLINK GATE AT EXISTING FENCE 32 REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 33 NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW AND LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING W/ BRICK INFILL BELOW TO MATCH EXISTING 34 NEW LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING 1 1 6 4 5 12 6 14 4 3 17 ADDITION ENTRY T/ ROOF 20' - 8" 33 23 25 28 20 34 | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR3.3BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 1/8" = 1'-0"1 SOUTH ELEVATION- EXISTING 1/8" = 1'-0"2 SOUTH ELEVATION- PROPOSED MATERIAL KEYNOTES 1 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 2 EXISTING PAINTED T & G WOOD SOFFIT 3 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS PANEL 4 EXISTING ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 5 EXISTING LIMESTONE SILL 6 EXISTING BRICK 7 EXISTING FRONT DOOR 8 EXISTING SHRUBS 9 EXISTING PAINTED ALUMINUM WRAPPED TRIM 10 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD SIDING 11 EXISTING CEDAR T & G SOFFIT 12 EXISTING PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS SIDING 13 EXISTING LIMESTONE WINDOW SURROUND 14 EXISTING CHAINLINK FENCE 15 EXISTING PAINTED WOOD PANEL DOOR 16 EXISTING WOOD FRAMED DECK AND RAILING 17 EXISTING GLASS BLOCK WINDOW 18 RECESSED LIGHTING IN NEW BEADBOARD SOFFIT TO MATCH GARAGE OVERHANG. 19 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD OPERABLE WINDOW WALL 20 CLEAR GLASS AND STEEL GUARDRAIL 21 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS LAP SIDING TO MATCH REAR ADDITION 22 PREFINISHED CEMENTITIOUS TRIM TO MATCH WINDOW CLADDING 23 18" GLASS CANOPY 24 DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD DOOR AND WINDOW 25 NEW BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 26 STEP LIGHT 27 NEW CEDAR STAIR AND LANDING TO MATCH EXISTING DECK 28 ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW TO MATCH EXISTING 29 FILL IN OPENING W/ BRICK TO MATCH EXISTING 30 NEW PAINTED FIBERGLASS EXTERIOR DOOR 31 NEW CHAINLINK GATE AT EXISTING FENCE 32 REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOWS 33 NEW DARK BRONZE ALUMINUM CLAD WINDOW AND LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING W/ BRICK INFILL BELOW TO MATCH EXISTING 34 NEW LIMESTONE SILL TO MATCH EXISTING UP WH WAF WAF FILL IN SUNKEN TUB & POUR NEW SLAB BEDROOM CL. CL. LIVING ROOM ENTRYSTUDIO/ GUEST BEDROOM BATH CEDAR CLOSET MECH. LAUNDRY GARAGE CL. LINEN CL. FP STORAGE TILE FLOORING NEW DOOR AND SIDELIGHTS NEW WOOD FLOORING TO MATCH EXISTING SINK, BASE CABINETS & UPPERS NEW LAUNDRY LOCATION SINK, BASE CABINETS & UPPERS NEW LAUNDRY LOCATION WALL HOOKS NEW EXTERIOR STAIR TO DECK REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW HIGH WINDOW AND SILL DECK ABOVE REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK W/ NEW WINDOW BOXWOOD, TYP. BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE BLUESTONE FLAGSTONE REAR PATIO FRONT PORCH BATH PACHYSANDRA, TYP. BOXWOODGRAVEL BED FILL IN EXISTING OPENING FILL IN EXISTING OPENING ADDITION 9' - 0 1/2" ADDITION 5' - 10" 27'-0" FRONT SETBACK 5'-0" SIDE SETBACK 9' - 8" 13' - 2 1/2" 3' - 6" | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR4.0BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 3/16" = 1'-0"1 FIRST FLOOR- PROPOSED FILL IN STAIR LIVING KITCHEN DINING FAMILY ROOM BATH M. BEDROOM M. BATH DECK BALCONY FP BASE CABINET W/ UPPER TUB TRANSLUCENT BARN DOOR FULL HEIGHT LINEN CABINET FLUSH PNL. DOORS NEW 3'-0" TALL BOTTOM MOUNTED CLEAR GLASS RAILING W/ STEEL POSTS AND TOP RAIL EXTEND EXISTING BALCONY TO BRICK WALL NEW FIXED WINDOWS BY NANAWALL TO MATCH OPERABLE WINDOWS NEW DOORS NEW DECKING AND STRUCTURE BELOW ENTRY ROOF BELOW TO DRAIN TO SCUPPER NANA WINDOW WALL MIRROR BEAM SKYLIGHT NANA WINDOW WALL 3' - 0" 3' - 0" REPLACE EXISTING GLASS BLOCK WINDOW W/ NEW NEW STEP TO FAMILY ROOM EXTEND BALCONY 7' - 8" BALCONY EXISTING 6' - 4 1/2" 17' - 4 1/2" 3' - 6" NEW STAIR AND LANDING TO EXISTING DECK DECK EXISTING 4' - 10 1/2" 27'-0" FRONT SETBACK 5'-0" SIDE SETBACK | 1234 sherman ave. | evanston | il | 60202 | t. 847.733.7300 | f.847.733.7303 | www.studiotalo.com | tal architecturestudi inc. © 2016 Date: Project #PR4.1BUSH RESIDENCE 07.19.16 1602 3/16" = 1'-0"1 SECOND FLOOR- PROPOSED 4. APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES of July 19, 2016. DRAFT Page 1 of 3 Preservation Commission MEETING MINUTES EVANSTON PRESERVATION COMMISSION Tuesday, July 19, 2016 Lorraine H. Morton Civic Center, 2100 Ridge Avenue, Room 2404 7:00 P.M. Members Present: Robert Bady, Ken Itle, Amy Riseborough, Tim Schmitt, Jack Weiss, and Diane Williams Members Absent: Elliott Dudnik, Sally Riessen Hunt, Julie Hacker and Karl Vogel Staff Present: Carlos D. Ruiz Preservation Coordinator Presiding Member: Diane Williams, Chair CALL TO ORDER / DECLARATION OF QUORUM With a quorum present, Chair Williams called the meeting to order at 7:11 p.m. OLD BUSINESS A. 917 Edgemere Court (LSHD) – Elliot Flaws, applicant. Construction of a new 2-story, brick and stucco single-family residence with an attached 1-story, 3-car garage in front. Applicable standards: [Construction] 1- 13, and 16 Chair Williams said there was no resubmission from the applicants for the Certificate of Appropriateness for 917 Edgemere Court. The Commission accepted into the record a packet of information from the Edgemere Court neighbors and an opinion from their attorney. Commissioner Weiss made a motion to continue the case to August 16, 2016, seconded by Commissioner Bady. Motion passed unanimously. B. 2623 Lincoln Street (L) – Consideration of Preservation Commission’s Report and Recommendation to City Council regarding David and Rebecca Kimbell application for rescission of landmark designation of their house at 2623 Lincoln Street – For action. The Commission reviewed the summary report prepared by City staff. On June 21, 2016, the Commission voted unanimously to recommend denial of rescission of landmark designation of 2623 Lincoln St property. Chair Williams asked to include in the report Mrs. Kimbell as one of the applicants as well. Also, to add in the text the exhibit number for the DRAFT Page 2 of 3 Preservation Commission Area III map; place Bristle’s national recognition of his work before his local recognition; and correctly notate Ordinance numbers with capital “O”. Include all attachments as listed. Commissioner W eiss said research shows that landmark homes do increase the value of properties. Chair Williams added that most data is on historic districts, not individual designations. There is recent data for this area (Area III) showing that there is no difference for this particular neighborhood. Chair Williams said she will address that and include the data in the report as an appendix. David Kimbell, owner of 2623 Lincoln St., said the Commission’s recommendation that his house at 2623 Lincoln Street, “still” meets criteria (A) 3 and (A) 4 is without historical evidence, since there is no Statement of Significance for it. Chair Williams said it is the Commission’s position that the house at 2623 Lincoln Street meets current criteria (A) 3 and (A) 4. The Commission deleted from the report the word “still”, since it would not make a difference in terms of the landmark status of the house. Commissioner Itle made a motion to approve the report and request the City Manager transmit it with memorandum (including the appendix by Chair Williams) to the City Council, seconded by Commissioner Riseborough. The motion passed unanimously. NEW BUSINESS No new business APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES of June 21, 2016. Commissioner Weiss made a motion to approve the minutes as corrected, seconded by Commissioner Riseborough. The motion passed unanimously. COMMITTEE REPORTS (Working Groups) Preservation Ordinance Review Subcommittee - Update. Chair Williams informed the Commission that the Subcommittee met on July 13th and continues its review of the Preservation Ordinance. The next meeting is on Tuesday, August 23rd at 8 a.m. VOLUNTEER REPORTS Design Guidelines Volunteers – Update Commissioner Weiss informed the Commission that the Design Guidelines volunteers have finished a draft of the first 4 pages of the Preservat ion Design Guidelines. STAFF REPORTS Carlos Ruiz stated the Environmental Board invited the Commission to attend their August 11, 2016 meeting. The Board is interested to hearing from the Commission regarding a proposed initiative to encourage City Council to fund a study in 2017 on City street lights and how to reduce green gas emissions. The Tallmadge street light poles are considered an iconic symbol of the City. Chair Williams said she will attend the Board’s meeting. DRAFT Page 3 of 3 Preservation Commission ADJOURNMENT Commissioner Riseborough made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 8:08 pm, seconded by Commissioner Schmitt. The motion passed unanimously. Respectfully Submitted, Carlos D. Ruiz Preservation Coordinator, Community Development Department