Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutORDINANCES-2000-056-O-0005/18/2000, 04/24/2000 0 56-0-00 AN ORDINANCE Designating the Northeast Evanston Historic District as an Evanston Historic District WHEREAS, Section 2-9-3, et seq. of the City Code of the City of Evanston has created the Evanston Preservation Commission; and WHEREAS, among the powers of said Commission found in Section 2-9-3 (g) is the power and duty to investigate and make recommendations to the City Council or its duly authorized committee concerning the adoption of ordinances designating areas, properties, structures, sites and objects as landmarks and districts; and WHEREAS, Section 2-9-4 of the City Code of the City of Evanston provides criteria . for designation of nominated districts and requires that every district must meet one or more of the specified criteria for designation; and WHEREAS, on October 19, 1999, the Northeast Evanston Historic District Association together with co -applicants Northwestern Neighbors Association and Save the Cottage Association presented to the Commission a nomination proposing the designation of a portion of Northeast Evanston as an Evanston Historic District; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the provisions of the Evanston Preservation Commission Ordinance, the Preservation Commission held public hearings on said nomination on November 17, 1999 followed by hearings on December 1, 1999, December 14, 1999, January 13, 2000 and January 26, 2000. That at said hearings, the Commission 0 considered testimony, and accepted written materials until February 1, 2000; and WHEREAS, due notice of said hearings was given in accordance with the requirements of the Evanston Preservation Commission Ordinance and all persons desiring to be heard were given an opportunity to be heard; and WHEREAS, after having heard and reviewed the nomination testimony, the written materials and all evidence adduced at said public hearings, the Commission made a written record and adopted a Resolution at its meeting on March 6, 2000, and determined that the nomination satisfied criterias two, three, five, and nine as set forth in the Ordinance and further found that the District had sufficient integrity of location, design, materials and workmanship to make it worthy of preservation or restoration, all as required by Section 2-9-4 (B) of said Ordinance; and WHEREAS, the Commission specifically found that criteria two was satisfied in that the District meets the criteria of "its identification with a person or persons who significantly • contributed to the historic, cultural, architectural, archeological or related aspects of the development of the City, state, midwester region or the United States"; and WHEREAS, the Commission found that the nomination meet the requirements of criteria three which states "as exemplification of an architectural type, style or design, distringuished by innovation, rarity, uniqueness or overall quality of design, detail, materials or craftmanship"; and WHEREAS, the Commission found that the nomination met the provisions of criteria five, to -wit, "its exemplification of important planning and urban design techniques distinguished by innovation, rarity, uniqueness or overall quality of design or detail'; and is 6A WHEREAS, the Commission found that the nomination met the requirements of • criteria nine, to -wit, "its unique location or distinctive physical appearance or presence representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood, community or the City"; and WHEREAS, the Commission further determined that the Northeast Evanston Historic District was truly important to the City of Evanston, its people, its culture and its history and met the criteria for designation as set forth in the Ordinance, and further recommended to the Mayor and City Council that the Northeast Evanston Historic District be designated as an Evanston Historic District; and WHEREAS, on March 9, 2000, the Report and Recommendation of the Preservation Commission was submitted to the Planning and Development Committee of the City is Council, which accepted same and submitted it to the City Council on March 13, 2000; and WHEREAS, pursuant to direction of the City Council on March 13, 2000, the Planning and Development Committee held a public meeting on April 12, 2000, upon due notice and heard testimony from all persons desiring to be heard; and WHEREAS, on April 24, 2000, the Planning and Development Committee considered the testimony received at its April 12, 2000 meeting and submitted the matter to City Council; and WHEREAS, the City Council, at its May 8, 2000 meeting directed the Planning and Development Committee to consider modifications to the boundaries of the nominated Northeast Evanston Historic District; and • M WHEREAS, the Planning and Development Committee held a public meeting on May 18, 2000, pursuant to due notice, receiving testimony, making a written record, and • voting to recommend that the City Council modify the boundaries of the nominated Northeast Evanston Historic District; and WHEREAS, said boundaries, as modified by the Planning and Development Committee on May 18, 2000, were further considered by the Committee at its May 22, 2000 meeting; and WHEREAS, the Planning and Development Committee at the aforesaid May 18, 2000 public meeting, voted to recommend that the City Council modify the boundaries of the Northeast Historic District as nominated to the boundaries as set forth in Appendix A, more particularly described in Appendix B, both attached hereto and made a part hereof; and • WHEREAS, the City Council has considered the report and recommendation of the Evanston Preservation Commission, including the record made at said public hearings and has determined that the nomination, as modified by the Planning and Development Committee, for the Northeast Evanston Historic District meets the criteria and standards set forth in the City Code of the City of Evanston and the designation of said Historic District is in the best interests of the City of Evanston; and WHEREAS, the City Council has determined the proceedings before the Evanston Preservation Commission were conducted and held in all respects according to law and the Planning and Development Committee proceedings were in accordance with City Council Rules; and . 4 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF is THE CITY OF EVANSTON:M SECTION ONE: That the City Council hereby finds the foregoing as fact and accepts and adopts the Report and Recommendation of the Evanston Preservation Commission, both as accepted and later modified by the Planning and Development Committee at its May 18, 2000 meeting, that the Northeast Evanston Historic District be designated as a Historic District, as described in Appendix A, more particularly described in Appendix B. The Preservation Commission Report of March 6, 2000 is appended hereto and made part hereof as Exhibit C. SECTION TWO: That the Northeast Evanston Historic District be and it is hereby established in accordance with the provisions of the Evanston Preservation Commission is Ordinance, Title 2, Chapter 9 of the City Code. Title 2 Chapter 9, Schedule B is hereby amended to list by address all properties within the said Northeast Evanston Historic District. That the boundaries of said District are set forth in the aforedescribed Appendix A and Appendix B. SECTION THREE: That the provisions, conditions and requirements of the Evanston Preservation District Commission Ordinance shall apply to all properties located in the Northeast Evanston Historic District from and after the effective date of this Ordinance. SECTION FOUR: All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict herewith are hereby repealed. • 5 SECTION FIVE: That this ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage, approval and publication in pamphlet form in the manner provided by law. • AYES: 6 NAYS: PASSED this DPc:(day of V��a ' , 2000. APPROVED this day of , 2000. Mayor ATTEST: it Clerk Appnito ,ed as to form: Corporation C nsel • L June 12, 2000 • PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT: * Ordinance 67-0-00 — Amendment to Section 7-2-6(D) 5C of City Code — Consideration of proposed Ordinance 67-0-00, which would permit Council waiver of the use of certain nondisposable food service and packaging articles in sidewalk cafes. * MARKED INTRODUCED — CONSENT AGENDA * Ordinance 73-0-00 — Amendments to City Code, Chapter 14 — Consideration of proposed Ordinance 73-0-00, which would amend Chapter 14 of the City Code, the Site Plan & Appearance Review regulations for sidewalk cafes. * MARKED INTRODUCED — CONSENT AGENDA HUMAN SERVICES: * Approval of Township Bills — Consideration of a recommendation that City Council approve the Township bills, payroll and medical payments for the month of May 2000 in the amount of $102,335.08. * APPROVED — CONSENT AGENDA MOTION AND ROLL CALL (9-0) * Special Event — Rotary International Picnic — Consideration of a request to hold the 7" annual Rotary International Staff Picnic on Friday, August 11, from 11:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. at Centennial Park. * APPROVED — CONSENT AGENDA MOTION AND ROLL CALL (9-0) * Special Event — YMCA Indian Guides & Princesses Lakefront Campout — Consideration of a request to hold the annual Indian Guides & Princesses Lakefront Campout on September 23-24 in Centennial Park. * APPROVED — CONSENT AGENDA MOTION AND ROLL CALL (9-0) • * Special Event — City of Hope's Walk for Hope — Consideration of a request to hold the 6" annual City of Hope Walk for Hope against breast cancer on Sunday, October 15, from 9:00 a.m. to noon at the lakefront, Centennial to Clark Square Park. * APPROVED — CONSENT AGENDA MOTION AND ROLL CALL (9-0) * Ordinance 72-0-00 — Annual Budget for Evanston Township — Consideration of proposed Ordinance 72-0-00, by which City Council, acting as Township Trustees, would enact the annual appropriation ordinance for the Town of the City of Evanston for the FY 4/1/00-3/3 1 /0 1. * MARKED INTRODUCED — CONSENT AGENDA OTHER COMMITTEES: * Resolution 62-R-00 — Amending Rule 9 of the City Council Rules and Organization — Consideration of proposed Resolution 62-R-00, which amends Rule 9 of the City Council Rules to create a City Council Budget Committee and assign responsibilities. * APPROVED — CONSENT AGENDA MOTION AND ROLL CALL (9-0) SEMEN Alderman Feldman moved to override Mayor Morton's veto of Ordinance 56-0-00— Northeast Historic Preservation Ordinance adopted by the City Council on May 22, 2000. Seconded by Alderman Bernstein. Alderman Engelman recalled when Council redrew boundaries, there was discussion of what support existed within • those boundaries. He reiterated that no preservation program could succeed without the support of people within the district. No one went door to door so that every property owner could voice an opinion on the redrawn district, rather Council was presented with petitions from 40 within the district who supported it. Petitions opposing the district total 53 and about 65 had no opinion; 40 people out of 160 is 25%, hardly overwhehning support. He stated no district should 12 June 12, 2000 be enacted if it is not needed. He observed that not one residential home would be torn down for an institutional use in • the RI district if the Mayor's veto is sustained because the Zoning Ordinance prevents residential property in an RI district from being turned into an institutional use. He suggested that the veto should be sustained for another reason. The community has said that they want the City Council to enter into negotiations with Northwestern University regarding a contribution. He did not believe it was good policy for Council, at the same time it asks the University to come to the table and enter into a dialogue, to send another message that was made by redrawing the boundary. This is not about preservation, but about Northwestern University and restrictions being imposed at the same time Council is asking them to engage in a dialogue on a contribution to the City and that would be inappropriate. He urged the Mayor's veto be sustained. Alderman Newman asked First Assistant Corporation Counsel Herb Hill if any rule or procedure had been violated during the process of considering this ordinance? Mr. Hill said throughout the process, all City rules, procedures, guidelines, ordinance standards were followed. Special Counsel, Richard Friedman, was retained by the Preservation Commission during their review, who worked closely with Corporation Counsel Jack Siegel and the Law Department. Mr. Siegel and the Law Department were involved with drafting the ordinance. Alderman Newman asked about the ethics complaint? Mr. Hill stated a letter was written to the Mayor, which she forwarded to the Board of Ethics. The matter is set for consideration in the next week or so. There were 10-12 issues raised in the letter. Alderman Newman stated V Ward people opposed to this ordinance were outnumbered by those who support it; noted matters on land use cannot be submitted to a plebiscite and balanced the interest of opponents versus proponents. For him a significant factor were the structures on Sheridan Road, which are not in a residential district but add to the residential character and beauty of the neighborhood and all of Evanston. These are structures that can or will go down unless Council has a voice. He noted every P&D Committee member was present at the May 22 meeting. Alderman Engelman made several suggestions, which were rejected. He found interesting the linkage to "Fair Share," and never knew of any interest by the Mayor in "Fair Share." He felt the people who worked on this ordinance deserved a hearing • and to have their work voted up or down. He did not think it was in the City's interest to link it to other City business. He hoped Council would override the veto; was confident the community would flourish with this ordinance in place. Alderman Feldman was content to listen to the 1st Ward alderman and the support he articulated, neighborhood organization support as well as letters and phone calls he received. He thought that was significant criteria that the district is wanted. He knows that it is needed. He stated the action taken at the last meeting caused anguish and struggle in many of the aldermen and was proud of the decision. They attempted to be Solomon -like and balance the needs with the values of the City. He was proud of the community people who struggled for passage of this ordinance. He urged his colleagues to override the veto, which he considered ill advised. Mayor Pro Tern Rainey could not chastise anybody for dragging in the "Fair Share" issue. It never occurred to her that this would include a debate on "Fair Share" and heard it done in a clever way by both sides. When they look at the current Preservation Ordinance, when a new district is brought forth, she suggested a careful poll be taken of owners in that district. She saw preservation districts as a good goal, not a lofty goal. If a district were established where there is deteriorating housing and, by declaring it a historic district people wanted to come in and enhance property, she thought that a tool for improving the quality of housing. She was going to vote to override the veto because she did not think those who opposed it would be harmed in any way. She was concerned about the only multi -family apartment building in the district; stated the ordinance ought to address that and that building should have been eliminated from the district because it could pose hardships. She did not think NU would be harmed by this ordinance and believes so because of the Foster/Maple garage. She stated the prospect of a seven -story garage going into that neighborhood was unlikely. Yet this Council made that happen due to economic development, land swaps, etc. She thought given the ability of NU to get Council to agree to the possibility of a structure at that site, probably means it can do anything, in any kind of a district, anyplace in town. She does not support that. She never thought this local designation had anything to do with negotiations with NU. The University was not going to help the City anyway. She recalled asking for an • engineer to help with the police outpost and NU refused. She hoped some member of the P&D Committee would refer the Preservation Ordinance for intense examination. 13 June 12, 2000 • Roll Call. Voting aye — Newman, Wynne, Bernstein, Kent, Rainey, Feldman. Voting nay — Drummer, Moran, Engelman. Motion carried (6-3). Alderman Kent left the meeting at this time. REPORT OF THE STANDING COMMITTEES ADMINISTRATION & PUBLIC WORKS: Resolution 43-R-00 — Parking Agreement with District #65 — Consideration of proposed Resolution 43-R-00, which authorizes the City Manager to execute an agreement with School District #65 for parking spaces in Lot 35 (Lincoln School). Alderman Feldman moved approval. Seconded by Alderman Wynne. Alderman Engelman asked who currently uses Lot #35 on the northeast corner of Judson and Main? Public Works Director David Jennings explained nighttime use is primarily residents (24-hour permits); daytime users are local businesses and their employees. Alderman Engelman asked the experience over the past two years on daytime permits? Mr. Jennings stated reasonably good, but not sold out. Mr. Jennings stated Lot #32 (east side Hinman, south of Main) and Lot #35 comprise the daytime permits. Alderman Wynne stated that Lot 935 has 55 spaces with 20 daytime permits sold there. The daytime permits allow parking in both lots #32 and #35. Alderman Engelman was concerned that they might be displacing one group of users for another. Mr. Jennings looked to see if there were enough vacancies in Lot #35 to accommodate 14 daytime parkers and there are. Alderman Wynne noted this is a wasting asset and they hope that teachers will park there instead of on the street. is Motion carried, no nays. Ordinance 38-0-00 — Prohibit Immobilizing Vehicles — Consideration of proposed Ordinance 38- 0-00, introduced May 8, 2000, by which City Council would prohibit private towing companies from immobilizing vehicles on private property. Alderman Feldman moved approval of Ordinance 38-0-00. Seconded by Alderman Drummer. Alderman Moran stated the City may want to regulate this activity; has heard from customers who have engaged this company that this is an effective regulatory tool and perhaps a more workable means of dealing with the problem it seeks to address. He recalled being towed in Chicago and how difficult the experience was. He noted Guardian Management Parking's flexibility toward this and that they brought the ordinance the Chicago City Council will vote on June 28. This ordinance does not prohibit booting in private lots, but provides a sensible regulatory framework. They learned from Mr. Hill at the A&PW Committee that the proposed ordinance was lifted from Chicago's current ordinance that prohibits booting. He thought that Chicago was going to do away with the flat-out prohibition of booting on private lots and work toward a regulatory scheme. He suggested they consider the pros and cons and, should they believe regulation is needed, take that action. He urged a "no" vote and to consider regulating this activity. Alderman Drummer shared the feelings of Alderman Moran. He has concluded this is not the worst thing that can happen to Evanstonians and could be a positive experience. He noted this company remains on -site in the parking lots all day. If the vehicle is booted, there is someone there to remove the boot. Compared to the agony plus the cost of towing a vehicle, this is reasonable. He suggested they take another look at this ordinance and consider how to modify it. They heard from a citizen who had been booted and she was not angry, rather was pleased that she did not have to deal with a towing company. He'noted Greatbank's president was cooperative and willing to have the City look at . modifications that could affect his operation. One question was the amount of time between parking the car and the citizen going to another business. The president was willing to wait 15 minutes. This is 15 minutes out of somebody's private lot. He did not think it was as bad as towing which costs $105 plus transportation and storage and the aggravation Appendix A City of Evanston Northeast Evanston Historic District Parcels Historic District .0 Vj A F.F1 200 0 200 400 Feet L- -- 5131/00 STREET COLFAX DARTMOUTH X STREET NOYES . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 HAVEN STREErJ GARRM I II SIMPSON STREET LU U PLACE OA L ZREET FOSTER STREET 0 • Appendix B NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT BOUNDARIES We boundaries of the Northeast Evanston Historic District are shown on Appendix A and are described verbally as follows: Beginning at the intersection of the East right-of-way line of Sheridan Road and the North right-of-way line of Emerson Street; thence West along the north line of Emerson Street to the East line of the public alley West of Orrington Avenue; thence North along the East line of said public alley to the North line of Foster Street; thence East along the North line of Foster Street to the West line of 715 Foster Street; thence North along the West property line of 715 Foster Street to its intersection with the South property line of 2014 Orrington Avenue; thence West along the South property line of 2014 Orrington Avenue to the Southwest corner of said property; thence North along the West property lines of 2014 through 2030 Orrington Avenue to the Northwest property corner of 2030 Orrington Avenue; thence East along the North line of 2030 Orrington Avenue to its intersection with the east line of public alley; thence North along the east line of said public alley to a point which is 100 feet South of the South right-of-way line of Simpson Street; thence West at right angles to the last described course and along the South property line of 2039 Sherman Avenue, produced West, to the West line of Sherman Avenue; thence North along the West line of Sherman Avenue to the North line of the first public alley South of Colfax Street; thence West along the North line of said public alley (also being the South property line of 802 to 822 Colfax Street) to the East line of Noyes Court; thence South along said East line, extended South, a distance of 50.81 feet to its intersection with the Eastward extension of the South property lines of 828 to 908 Colfax Street; thence West along said Eastward extension and the South property lines of 828 to 908 Colfax Street to its intersection with the East line of the Chicago Transit Authority Elevated right-of- way line; thence Northwesterly along the said East line of the Chicago Transit Authority Elevated right-of-way &ne to its intersection with the South line of the public alley South of and parallel to Lincoln Street; thence East along said alley South line to the West line of the Sherman Avenue; thence North along said West line of Sherman Avenue to its intersection with the centerline of Lincoln Street; thence East along the centerline of Lincoln Street to the West line of the public alley East of Orrington Avenue; thence South along the West line of said public alley to its intersection with the South line of the public alley North of and parallel to Colfax Street; thence East along the South line of said public alley to its intersection with the West line of the vacated alley West of and parallel to Sheridan Road; thence South along the West line of said vacated alley extended South to its intersection with the North line of Haven Street; thence East along the North line of Haven Street to its intersection with the East line of Sheridan Road; thence South along the East line of Sheridan Road to the point of beginning. 0 EXHIBIT C Evanston Preservation Commission Resolution Page 1 of 3 — March 6, 2000 CITY OF EVANSTON • EVANSTON PRESERVATION COMMISSION A RESOLUTION Requesting the City Manager to Transmit The Evanston Preservation Commission's Recommendation and Report that the City Council Designate the Northeast Evanston Historic District as an Evanston Historic District WHEREAS, On October 19, 1999 The Northeast Evanston Historic District Association ("NEHDA") along with co -applicants, Northwestern Neighbors and Save the Cottage Association (collectively, "Applicants"), presented to the Evanston Preservation Commission (the "Commission") a nomination (the "Nomination") proposing the designation of a portion of Northeast Evanston as a Local Evanston Historic District; and goWHEREAS, in accordance with the Historic Preservation Ordinance (Section 2-9-1 et seq. of the Municipal Code) (the "Ordinance") the Commission began a review process; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the Ordinance, the Commission notified property owners of the receipt of the nomination; and WHEREAS, thereafter the Commission scheduled a public hearing. The public hearing commenced on November 17, 1999, and it was continued on December 1, 1999, December 14, 1999, January 13, 2000, and January 26, 2000; and WHEREAS, the Commission accepted written materials until February 1, Is 2000 at the close of the public hearing; and Evanston Preservation Commission Resolution Page 2 of 3 — March 6, 2000 WHEREAS, on February 1, 2000 and February 8, 2000, the Commission • deliberated and evaluated the Nomination, testimony heard at the public hearing and written materials; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE EVANSTON PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF EVANSTON, COOK COUNTY, ILLINOIS: Sectionl: The Commission determines that the proposed Northeast Evanston Historic District is found to be in conformity with criteria in Section 2-9-4 (A) 2, 3, 5, 9 and item 2-9-4(B). Section 2: The Commission recommends that the City Council designate the Northeast Evanston Historic District as an Evanston Historic District. Section 3: The report of the Commission's findings is approved in • substantially the form of the preliminary report submitted to this meeting. The Chair and the Preservation Coordinator may make such corrections and modifications thereto without change in substance as they shall deem appropriate, consistent with this resolution. Section 4: The City Manager is hereby requested to transmit the Commission's Recommendation and Report to the Mayor and the City Council, within five business days hereof. Section 5: The Preservation Coordinator shall send the report upon property owners in accordance with Section 2-9-5 (F) of the Ordinance. Section 6: That this Resolution shall be in full force and effect from and • after the date of its passage and approval in the manner required by law. • • Adopted: 3 — ATTEST: F:vwston Prtscrvation Conn fission Rcsoludon Page 3 or 3 - March 6. 2100 , 2000, Yeas 8 , Nays �C _ J. Kirk Irwin Evans to Preservation Commission Chair ,4,,�RAza, G3.ab . o0 George Halik Secretary 3 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT Title 2 Chapter 9, Scheduled B (Addendum) • Northeast Evanston Historic District - List by address of all properties C = Contributing Structure; NC = Non -Contributing Structure Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 619 Colfax Street S.F. (dorm) 1912 C 624 Colfax Street S. F. 1915 C 625 Colfax Street S. F. (office) 1910 C 628 Colfax Street S. F. 1916 C 628 Colfax Street Play House 1917 C 628 Colfax Street Garage unk NC 629 Colfax Street S. F. 1907 C 629 Colfax Street Garage 1962 NC 714 Colfax Street S. F. 1908 C 714 Colfax Street Garage mov. 1948 C 720 Colfax Street S. F. 1917 C 720 Colfax Street Garage 1973 NC 724 Colfax Street S.F. 1906 C 724 Colfax Street Garage 1925 C 725 Colfax Street Dormitory 1963 NC 728 Colfax Street S. F. 1907 C 728 Colfax Street Garage 1983 NC 732 Colfax Street S. F. 1907 C 732 Colfax Street Garage 1998 NC • 735 802 Colfax Street Colfax Street S. F. S.F. 1935 1908 C C 802 Colfax Street Garage 1964 NC 805 Colfax Street S.F. 1916 C 806 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 806 Colfax Street Garage 1976 NC 807 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 807 Colfax Street Garage 1940 C 810 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 810 Colfax Street Shed 1928 C 811 Colfax Street S. F. 1907 C 811 Colfax Street Garage 1911 C 812 Colfax Street S. F. 1908 C 812 Colfax Street Garage 1912 C 815 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 815 Colfax Street Garage 1931 C 818 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 818 Colfax Street Garage 1910 C 819 Colfax Street S. F. 1908 C 819 Colfax Street Garage 1921 C 822 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 822 Colfax Street Garage 1918 C 823 Colfax Street S. F. 1908 C 823 Colfax Street Barn 1908 C • 827 Colfax Street S. F. 1911 C 827 Colfax Street Garage 1940 C 828 Colfax Street j S.F. 1908 C May 22, 2000 Page 1 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 828 Colfax Street Garage 1911 C 900 Colfax Street S. F. 1908 C • 900 Colfax Street Barn 1909 C 901 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 901 Colfax Street Garage 1990 NC' 904 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 904 Colfax Street Barn 1909 C 905 Colfax Street S.F. 1910 C 905 Colfax Street Garage 1919 C 909 Colfax Street S.F. 1909 C 909 Colfax Street Garage 1923 C 911 Colfax Street S.F. 1939 C 618-24 Colfax Street S.F. 1915 C 618-24 Colfax Street Garage unk C 617 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1909 C 617 Dartmouth Place Garaqe unk C 620 Dartmouth Place Parking Lot NC 627 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1909 C 627 Dartmouth Place Garage 1915 C 630 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1925 C 619 Emerson Street S.F. (office) 1922 C 633 Emerson Street Student Health Center 1960 NC 711 Emerson Street S.F. 1890 C 711 Emerson Street Garage unk C 717 Emerson Street Apt. 1964 NC 600 Foster Street Offices 1999 NC 617 Foster Street Student Recreation Center 1973 NC • 629 Foster Street Religious Center 1999 NC 634 Foster Street S. F. 1870 C 709 Foster Street S. F. 1880 C 715 Foster Street S. F. 1911 C 714-16 Foster Street Apt. 1901 C 618 Garrett Place S.F. (office) 1914 C 618 Garrett Place Garage 1916 C 624 Garrett Place S.F. 1916 C 624 Garrett Place Garage 1 1924,1945 1 C 625 Garrett Place S.F. 1 1924 C 625 Garrett Place Garage 1940 C 628 Garrett Place S.F. 1912 C 628 Garrett Place Garage 1939 C 629 Garrett Place 2-Flat 1916 C 629 Garrett Place Garage 1 1917,1945 1 C 632 ( Garrett Place S. F. 1921 C 632 ( Garrett Place Garage 1987 NC 638 ( Garrett Place S. F. 1921 C 601-15 Garrett Place Student Apartments 1959 NC 621-23 Garrett Place Student Apartments 1961 NC 600 ( Haven Street Iffices, Library, Dormitory, 1929 C 600 Haven Street I Wheeler Hall Addition 1955 NC 612 Haven Street Dormitory 1955 NC • 617 Haven Street S.F. (office) 1911 C 625 Haven Street S.F. (office) 1914 C May 22, 2000 Page 2 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 625 Haven Street Garage 1919 C 629 Haven Street S.F. 1913 C • 629 Haven Street Garage unk NC 638-40 Haven Street Double House 1963 NC 617 Library Place S.F. (office) 1894 C 618 Library Place Offices 1993 NC 619 Library Place 2-Flat 1915 C 619 Library Place Coach House 1917 C 620 Library Place S.F. (office) 1903 C 625 Library Place S. F. 1921 C 625 Library Place Garage 1966 NC 626 Library Place S.F. (office) 1896 C 627 Library Place S.F. 1894 C 627 Library Place Garage 1937 C 628 Library Place Apt. 1971 NC 630 Library Place S.F. 1927 C 637-43 Library Place Apt. 1913 C 637-43 Library Place Garage 1929 C 640 Lincoln Street School 1915 C 616 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1900 C 617 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1912 C 617 Noyes Street Garage 1927 C 624 Noyes Street S. F. 1902 C 624 Noyes Street Garage 1945 C 625 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1898 C 629 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1912 C • 719 Noyes Street S.F. 1898 C 719 Noyes Street Garage 1911 C 725 Noyes Street S.F. 1898 C 725 Noyes Street Garage 1926 C 718-34 Noyes Street Co-op Apt. 1927 C 1900 Orrington Avenue Apt. 1914 C 1906 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1875 C 1906 Orrington Avenue Garage 1967 NC 1910 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1906 C 1910 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 1914 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1914 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 1915 Orrington Avenue 2-Flat 1916 C 1918 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1918 Orrington Avenue Garage 1916 C 1922 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1896 C 1922 Orrington Avenue Barn unk C 1926 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1926 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 1927 Orrington Avenue Dormitory 1970 NC 1930 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1930 Orrington Avenue Garage 1921 C 1934 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C • 1934 Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C 1936 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1894 C 1936 Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C May 22, 2000 Page 3 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 1940 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1940 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C • 1941 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1941 C 1942 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1942 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 1945 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1955 NC 1946 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1946 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2001 Orrington Avenue Double House 1892 C 2005 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2005 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2010 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2010 Orrington Avenue Garage 1936 C 2011 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2011 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2014 Orrington Avenue 2-Flat 1903,1960s NC 2015 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1910 C 2015 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1910 C 2018 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2018 Orrington Avenue Garage 1920 C 2019 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2019 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2020 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1885 C 2020 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2023 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1978 NC 2023 Orrington Avenue Garage 1978 NC 2024 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1880 C • 2026 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1903 C 2026 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2027 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1875 C 2027 Orrington Avenue Garage 1997 NC 2030 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1903 C 2030 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2032 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2034 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2036 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2036 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2036 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2039 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2039 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2040 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2040 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2043 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1928 C 2043 Orrington Avenue Garage 1928 C 2047 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1928 C 2047 Orrington Avenue Garage 1928 C 2102 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2102 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2103 2103 Orrington Avenue Orrington Avenue S.F. Garage 1895 1924 C C • 2106 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2106 Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C May 22, 2000 Page 4 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 2110 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1898 C 2110 Orrington Avenue Garage 1985 NC • 2111 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 NC 2112 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1893 C 2112 Orrington Avenue Garage 1990 NC 2112 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2118 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2118 Orrington Avenue Garage 1918 C 2118 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2121 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2121 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2122 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2122 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2126 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2126 Orrington Avenue Garage 1953 NC 2127 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1903 C 2127 Orrington Avenue Garage 1966 NC 2130 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1915 C 2130 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2131 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1965 NC 2131 Orrington Avenue Garage 1966 NC 2134 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1911 C 2134 Orrington Avenue Garage 1972 NC 2135 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1902 C 2135 Orrington Avenue Garage 1913 C • 2138 2138 Orrington Avenue Orrington Avenue Garage S.F. 1920 1921 C C 2145 Orrington Avenue Double House 1963 NC 2146 -Orrington Avenue S.F. 1912 C 2146 Orrington Avenue Garage 1920 C 2203 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2203 Orrington Avenue Garage 1979 NC 2204 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2204 Orrington Avenue Garage 1904 C 2206 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1912 C 2206 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2207 Orrington Avenue S.F. - 1900 C 2207 Orrington Avenue Garage 1985 NC 221'4 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2215 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2215 Orrington Avenue Garage 1969 NC 2218 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2219 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2219 Orrington Avenue Garage 1936 C 2222 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2233 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2233 Orrington Avenue Garage 1937 C 2236 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2236 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1906 C • 2243 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1892 C 2243 Orrington Avenue Garage 1967 NC 2244 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1906 C May 22, 2000 Page 5 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 2244 Orrington Avenue Garaqe 1917 C 2246 Orrington Avenue S.F..- 1915 C • 2246 Orrington Avenue Garage 1917 C 2247 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2247 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2252 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1914 C 2252 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2255 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2255 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2302 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2302 Orrington Avenue Garage 1927 C 2306 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1875 C 2306 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1926 C 2306 Orrington Avenue Garaqe 1993 NC 2307 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2307 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2314 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1927 C 2315 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2315 Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C 2316 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2316 Orrington Avenue Garage 1912 C 2316 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2320 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2320 Orrington Avenue Garage 1998 NC 2323 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2323 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2326 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C • 2326 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2330 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2330 Orrington Avenue Garage 1921 C 2331 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2340 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2344 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2344 Orrington Avenue Garaqe 1919 C 2408 Orrington Avenue School 1907 C 2001-03 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 2032-34 Orrington Avenue Double House 1894 C 1902 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1901 C 1908 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1892 C 1914 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1884 C 1918 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1922 C 1922 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1911 C 1936 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1893 C 1940 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1894 C 2000 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1921 C 2006 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) C 2010 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1917 C 2016 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1893 C 2036 Sheridan Road Vacant Land C 2040 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1905 C • 2040 Sheridan Road Garage C 2044 Sheridan Road S.F. 1901 C May 22, 2000 Page 6 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 2044 Sheridan Road Garage C • 2046 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1910 C 2110 Sheridan Road Religious Center 1967 NC 2039 Sherman Avenue 2-Flat 1909 C 2043 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2107 Sherman Avenue Town House 1972 NC 2109 Sherman Avenue Town House 1972 NC 2111 Sherman Avenue Town House 1972 NC 2115 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2115 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2115 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2119 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2119 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2123 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2123 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2125 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2125 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2129 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1896 C 2129 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2131 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1893 C 2131 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2135 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2135 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2137 "Sherman Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2137 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2141 2141 "Sherman Sherman Avenue Avenue 2-Flat Garage 1905 unk C NC 2145 Sherman Avenue 2-Flat 1905 C 2145 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2147 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2147 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2149 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2149 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2151 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2151 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2201 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1915 C 2201 Sherman Avenue Garage 1920 C 2205 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2205 Sherman Avenue Garage 1928 C 2207 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2207 Sherman Avenue Garage 1925 C 2211 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2211 Sherman Avenue Garage 1995 NC 2233 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2233 Sherman Avenue Garage 1997 NC 2235 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2237 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1898 C 2237 Sherman Avenue Garage _ unk C 2241 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2241 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2249 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2249 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC May 22, 2000 Page 7 of 8 NORTHEAST EVANSTON HISTORIC DISTRICT 2253 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2253 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC • 2301 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1911 C 2301 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2305 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2305 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2309 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1904 C 2309 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2311 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1904 C 2311 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2315 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2315 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2319 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2319 Sherman Avenue Garage 1950 NC 2346 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2346 "Sherman Avenue Garage 1919 C 2351 Sherman Avenue S.F. (office) 1941 C 718-24 Simpson Street Apt. 1909 C 721-31 Simpson Street Apt. 1916 C r] Ll May 22, 2000 Page 8 of 8 EXHIBIT C Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 1 of 11— March 6, 2000 E City of Evanston Evanston Preservation Commission Report to the City Council Recommendation that the Northeast Evanston Historic District be Designated as an Evanston Historic District March 6, 2000 To the Honorable Mayor and the City Council of the City of Evanston: Ladies and Gentlemen: The Evanston Preservation Commission, having completed its deliberations, has determined that the Northeast Evanston Historic District should be designated as an Evanston Historic District. Pursuant to Section 2-9-4 of the City Code of the City of Evanston, the Evanston Preservation Commission recommends that the City Council is designate said district as an Evanston Historic District, and in support of this recommendation, the Preservation Commission submits the following report. PROCEDURAL HISTORY On October 19, 1999 The Northeast Evanston Historic District Association, along with co -applicants, Northwestern Neighbors Association and Save the Cottage Association, presented to the Evanston Preservation Commission (the "Commission") a Nomination (the "Nomination") proposing the designation of a portion of Northeast Evanston as an Evanston Historic District. In accordance with the Historic Preservation Ordinance (Section 2-9-1 et seq. of the Evanston City Code) (the "Ordinance") the Commission began a review process that included a public hearing. The Commission evaluated the Nomination, testimony heard at the public hearing and written submittals. • The Commission has determined that the Northeast Evanston Historic District, the 1 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 2 of 11— March 6, 2000 boundaries of which are set forth on Appendix A, should be designated as an Evanston • Historic District. Pursuant to the Ordinance, the Commission notified property owners of the receipt of the Nomination. Thereafter, the Commission scheduled the public hearing. The public hearing commenced on November 17, 1999, and was continued on December 1, 1999, December 14, 1999, January 13, 2000, and January 26, 2000. The Commission accepted written materials until February 1, 2000. The Commission met in two sessions to deliberate upon the evidence, on February 1, 2000 and February 8, 2000. The Commission reviewed the Nomination and all other testimony, including written and spoken testimony from all concerned parties. At a meeting held March 6, 2000, the Commission approved this report by a vote of eight in favor and none against. In addition to this report, the Commission submits herewith the following: 0- Appendix A. Boundary map of the proposed Northeast Evanston Historic District. Appendix B. Designation of Contributing and Non -Contributing structures. Appendix C. List of documents in the record of the proceedings, including Nomination, transcripts of hearings and meetings, notices and certificates of mailings and written materials received and made part of the record. [The record is available for public inspection at the office of the City Clerk and the Preservation Coordinator.] CRITERIA The Ordinance outlines a specific procedure by which nominated landmarks and or districts shall be taken under consideration. The Ordinance requires that a district have definable boundaries and that the buildings comprising the district be classified as • contributing or non-contributing structures depending upon their physical characteristics. 6 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 3 of 11 — March 6, 2000 The Ordinance states that the proposed district must meet at least one of the ten • criteria for designation listed in Section 2-9-4(A). In addition, the Ordinance states that the district must also agree with Section 2-94(B); sufficient integrity of location, design, materials and workmanship to make it worthy of preservation or restoration. The district is found to be in conformity with criteria 2, 3, 5, 9, and item (B). The significance of the district will be described in relation to each of these criteria. Criterion 2 Criterion 2 states: "Its identification with a person or persons who significantly contributed to the historic, cultural, architectural, archaeological or related aspect of the development of the City, State, Midwest region or the United States." The Nomination lists several persons who contributed to these aspects of the r development of the city, state, region, or country. The Nomination lists many architects • ti associated with the district whose work is of national merit, including Thomas Eddy Tallmadge and Vernon S. Watson, Ernest A. Mayo, George W. Maher, Myron Hunt, William Holabird, Robert Steely DeGolyer, Howard Van Doren Shaw and Dwight Perkins. Prominent architects who lived in Evanston and designed houses in the Northeast Evanston Historic District include Charles Robert Ayars, Edgar Ovet Blake, and Stephen A. Jennings, among others. The district is identified with many local persons who influenced the development of the city and region, including, Thomas B. Carson, Charles A. Hemphill, Carl W. Johnson, S. S. Neal, James T. Tait, and James Wigginton, among others. The 1915 Blue Book lists 260 residents of whom some were university • professors, doctors, lawyers and business people who lived in the district. Some of the M Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 4 of I I — March 6, 2000 residents include Florence Walmth, founder and first managing director of the Cradle, • Walter Dill Scott, Northwestern University president, Catherine Waugh McCulloch, first women nominated to the electoral college, Edgar Kirk Warren, major contributor to the 1917 Plan for Evanston, and William Andrew Dyche, elected alderman of the Seventh Ward in the first city election in 1892 and elected mayor in 1895. Criterion 3 Criterion 3 states: "Its exemplification of an architectural type, style or design distinguished by innovation, rarity, uniqueness or overall quality of design, detail, materials or craftsmanship." Buildings in the district are predominantly of the residential type. They exemplify exceptional quality in their design, detail, materials and craftsmanship. Within this singular building type there are many architectural expressions illustrated in designs by 0 several significant architects. The buildings within the district are of a consistent high quality, well detailed and well designed, and are well executed through exceptional craftsmanship. Examples of this include, but are not limited to, 714 and 708 Milburn Street. 714 Milburn Street is a Prairie Style house designed by Ernest Mayo. Examples of its quality design are seen in the design of the entry portico with a trellis and the arch over the center window on the upper level. The house immediately to the east, 708 Milburn Street, is a Georgian Revival house of nearly the same size and scale of 714 Milburn Street. It is also executed in an exceptional manner. Other similar examples of fine craftsmanship and design include 715 Monticello Place, 806 Ingleside Place, and 2235 Sherman Avenue, to name a few. An example of fine craftsmanship and innovative development is the Milburn Park development dating • 4 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 5 of I I — March 6, 2000 from 1937. • The Commission noted that an overwhelming number of homes in the district have had very few alterations made to them as seen from the public way, thereby maintaining much of their original characteristics and quality workmanship. In general, the homes in the district convey a strong sense of architectural integrity. An overwhelming number of homes in the district were listed as contributing structures. The homes in the district are exemplary of the stylistic variety of homes typically built between the 1890's and 1940's in a prosperous area. Criterion 5 Criterion 5 states: "Its exemplification of important planning and urban design techniques distinguished by innovation, rarity, uniqueness or overall quality of design or • detail." The Nomination lists several examples of urban planning techniques that were unique or innovative. The Nomination refers to the 1917 Plan for Evanston and the subsequent 1921 Zoning Ordinance that was the first in Illinois. Daniel H. Burnham Jr., Dwight Perkins and Thomas Eddy Tallmadge, all architects of national significance, were on the first Evanston Plan Commission. Burnham's father is the author of the Plan for the City of Chicago and several other city plans around the country including the Restoration of the Mall in Washington, DC, and the Plan for San Francisco. Burnham Jr. had a significant role in running Burnham and Company at the time of his involvement with the Evanston Plan. It was the 1917 Plan and the 1921 Zoning Ordinance that set the residential character of the District. It is rare and unique to have architects of the stature • of Burnham, Tallmadge, and Perkins as contributing authors of the first Comprehensive 5 Plan for one's community. Criterion 9 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 6 of I I — March 6, 2000 Criterion 9 states: "Its unique location or distinctive physical appearance or presence representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood, community or the City." The district clearly represents visual features' familiar and established within the City of Evanston through the significant number of high quality residential buildings. Such cohesiveness results from a consistency of size, scale, massing, detail, and quality workmanship. Criterion 9 also applies very directly to this district because the three broad parkways of Sherman Avenue, Orrington Avenue, and Sheridan Road with their one -hundred foot rights -of -way provide a distinct visual appearance to the district. In • addition, it is the only area within Evanston to have three consecutive one hundred -foot is rights-of-way. ITEM (B) (INTEGRITY Item (B) states: "Integrity of Landmarks and Districts: Any area, property, - structure, site or object that meets any one or more of the criteria in subsection 2-94(A) shall also have sufficient integrity of location, design, materials and workmanship to make it worthy of preservation or restoration." The integrity of the district is characterized by houses having similar massing and scale and having a consistent street and alley pattern. The integrity of the District is strengthened by the relationship of buildings to streets and the streetscape itself. Another characteristic showing integrity throughout the district is the consistent pattern of main - house -and -outbuilding --usually a garage, but sometimes a coach house. What makes all • 2 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 7 of I I — March 6, 2000 of this significant is the consistency of these characteristics within the boundaries of the is district, the variety of stylistic expression within one building type, and the quality of the workmanship throughout. The integrity and consistency of the district is not compromised, but is strengthened by different stylistic expressions. Examples of consistent of size, scale and mass within a multiplicity of stylistic expressions include; 733, 731, and 729 Lincoln Street. The house on the corner 733 Lincoln Street is listed as an American Four Square, but has some Prairie Style details. The middle house, 731 Lincoln Street, is classical with a Corinthian portico. The house at 729 Lincoln Street has a gabled front and is simply detailed. Although of differing styles, they relate to one -another in scale and massing. The Commission determined that the district has integrity of location. The boundaries of the district are visually evident and clear. Furthermore, most of the • buildings remain on their original sites. The district has integrity of design, materials, and workmanship as seen in a significant number of contributing buildings distributed consistently throughout the district. The criterion is met since there is a distribution of contributing buildings throughout the district and because of the 'high quality of landscaped settings which occur between the buildings. CRITICAL FEATURES OF THE DISTRICT Materials and Construction The features critical to the district are represented by several exterior cladding materials including face brick veneer, clapboard wood siding, and stucco, with some stone masonry bearing wall construction. Most of the houses are made of wood framing • and clad in a variety of materials. The institutional buildings include face brick cladding 7 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 8 of i i — March 6, 2000 at Kendall College, stone masonry construction at Seabury-Westem Theological • Seminary, and stucco veneer at the Roycemore School. Residential and Institutional Buildings The district is primarily residential in character with a few substantial institutional buildings placed within and alongside residential structures. Significantly, the institutional buildings are designed to meet the scale of the adjacent residences. The eave lines of the institutional buildings are usually very low and kept to one story or lower. The Kendall College buildings have an articulated first floor. Seabury-Westem Theological Seminary is designed to a residential scale by means of gothic detailing as seen in the articulation of arches and buttresses. The institutional buildings in the district have well -developed intermediate zones in keeping with its residential character. This is evident at the Roycemore School, where the entire complex of buildings wraps around an • exterior courtyard. The district also includes structures originally built as residences, but which now house institutional uses. Such structures are included in the District because the criteria for review relate to the architecture, the built structures, and the surrounding spaces, not the particular use of a building at any given time. Therefore, a structure currently used as an institutional office is considered a residential house for the purposes of architectural review. Current office use does not change the architecture of the building but contributes to the residential character of the district. Three Components of the District Three components to the residential character of the district include the private homes, the streets and alleys, and the spaces between the houses and streets. All three of • 8 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 9 of 11— March 6, 2000 these are of a consistent high quality throughout the district and contribute significantly • to the integrity of the district as a whole. Viewing the houses in isolation from one another does not fully consider the architectural significance of this district. The houses in the district are of a consistent high quality, as seen in their materials, workmanship and design. They are of a consistent scale and are placed relative to one another on individual lots in a way that creates a consistent streetscape in some cases, and in other cases, creates vistas to Lake Michigan. Porches, verandas, walkways, and terraces in view of the public exist in privately owned areas. The development of this intermediate area allows the individual buildings to be viewed within a landscaped setting. The variety of architectural expressions within these elements and the landscaped setting between, taken as a whole, is irreplaceable. The pattern of main house and outbuilding • The map included in the Nomination shows this pattern. Although there are some houses in the district with attached garages, the primary pattern illustrates that a secondary structure at a rear alley typically exists. In most cases, this secondary structure serves as automobile storage. BOUNDARIES; CONTRIBUTING BUILDINGS Upon consideration of these and other issues outlined in the Ordinance, and upon a complete review of the evidence presented in the Nomination and in the public hearings, the Commission recommends approval of the list of contributing structures included in Nomination with the exception that buildings dating from 1950 to the present date be classified as non-contributing; buildings dating from 1949 and earlier shall be • classified as contributing or non-contributing as they are listed in the Nomination; and 9 Evanston Preservation Commission Report Page 10 of 11— March 6, 2000 even with the modification of post-1949 contributing structures to non-contributing structures, the boundaries of the proposed district shall be established as proposed in the • Nomination. The reasons for the revision are as follows: First, a change in architectural expression occurs in the district in buildings built in 1950 and later. Post-1950 houses tend spread more horizontally when compared to pre-1950 structures. They tend to have less wall surface and greater roof areas. The window areas in post-1950 houses tend to be greater than pre-1950 houses and porches tend to be minimized. In post-1950 houses the placement of windows is not often axial and there is a tendency for the houses to be of a light color. Second, the integrity of the district was already established by 1950. This includes the integrity of location as well as exceptional workmanship, design, and materials. • Pre-1950 buildings are distributed evenly throughout the district in a manner that supports the proposed boundaries. The boundaries were determined by examining where physical barriers, institutional uses, changes in land use and building age occur. The boundaries were supported by the Nomination and in the testimony heard at the hearing. The classification of post-1950 buildings as non-contributing structures does not affect the boundaries as proposed because many of the post-1950 buildings built within the District are infill buildings constructed within otherwise completed streets. The District is comprised of streets and exterior spaces between buildings that remain unaffected by the inclusion of intermittent contemporary designs. Examples of contemporary structures that are non- contributing but allow the qualities of the district to be seen around them are the houses at the east end of Clinton Place. These houses do not • 10 Fvanston Preservation Coenntission Rtport Pagc t 1 of l t — March 6, 2V)0 interfere with the vista that is formed toward the lake. • PROPOSED GUIDELINES C: The current standards for review set forth in the Ordinance should be used in reference to the buildings in the district. The current standards are sufficiently flexible to allow the Commission the latitude to address the characteristics of the district effectiv* when they arise in the future. U)"VCL USION The Commission has dcteratine d that the Nurtheact Evanston Historic District is truly irnportant to the City of Evanston, its people, its culture and its history. The district meets the criteria for designation as set forth in the Ordinance. Therefore, the Commission confidently submits this recommendation to the Mayor and City Council that the Northeast Evanston Historic District be designated as an Evanston Historic District. Respectfully submitted, Evanston Qreservation Commission 1 Date: ?, -p6 - tS9> J. Kirk Irwin, Chairman Date: M•1*'oo Gcorge 11alik, Secretary 0 11 0 APPENDIX B CONTRIBUTING AND NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 615 Central Street S.F. 1955 NC 616 Central Street S.F. 1909 C 616 Central Street Garage 1924 C 621 Central Street S.F. 1956 NC 624 Central Street S.F. 1909 C 624 Central Street Garage 1913 C 628 Central Street S.F. 1911 C 628 Central Street Garage 1988 NC 630 Central Street S.F. 1909 C 630 Central Street Garage 1995 NC 639 I Central Street j S.F. 1919 I C 639 Central Street Pool House 1971 N NC 711 Central Street S.F. 1922 C 711 Central Street Garage 1922 C 714 Central Street S.F. 1923 N C 714 Central Street Garage 1941 I C 717 717 ( Central Street Central Street S.F. Garage 1925 I 1925 C C 719 I Central Street S.F. + 1927 I C 720 Central Street S.F. 1924 N C 720 Central Street Garage j 1924 , C 721 I Central Street I S.F. I 1921 I C 721 ) Central Street Garage 1921 I C 724 N Central Street S.F. I 1921 I C 724 Central Street Garage I unk C 725 Central Street S.F. N 1924 C 725 Central Street Garage 1992 NC 728 Central Street S.F. 1957 I NC 729 j Central Street S.F. 1924 C 729 Central Street + Garage j 1924 C 730 I Central Street S.F. 1929 C 730 Central Street + Garage 1929 C 735 I Central Street S.F. 1923 C 736 Central Street S.F. j 1929 C 736 Central Street Garage unk N NC 739 Central Street S.F. 1875 N C 739 N Central Street Garage I 1985 I NC 745 Central Street S.F. N 1924 C 745 Central Street Garaqe 1937 C 801 Central Street S.F. 1957 NC 805 I Central Street I S.F. 1957 NC 807 Central Street S.F. 1957 NC 811 I Central Street S.F. 1921 C Appendix B: Page 1 Number Street Building Type Single Family/ Date Status Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 811 Central Street Garage unk NC 815 Central Street S.F. 1961 NC 817 Central Street S.F. 1923 C 817 Central Street Garage 1923 C 609 Clinton Place S.F. 1954 NC 610 Clinton Place S.F. 1954 NC 615 Clinton Place S.F. 1955 NC 615 Clinton Place Garage unk NC 616 Clinton Place S.F. 1955 NC 625 Clinton Place + S.F. 1923 C N 627 Clinton Place + S.F. 1937 C 630 Clinton Place S.F. 1927 C 4M I Gunton Place Garage unk NC 716 Clinton Place S.F. 1915 C 716 Clinton Place Garage 1930 C 722 Clinton Place j S.F. 1913 C 722 Clinton Place + Garage 1929 C 724 Clinton Place + S.F. 1925 C 726 Clinton Place S.F. 1898 C 727 Clinton Place S.F. 1912 C 727 Clinton Place Garage 1925 C 731 Clinton Place + S.F. 1912 C 731 Clinton Place Garage 1959 N NC 734 N Clinton Place S.F. 1923 C 734 Clinton Place Garage 1923 C 735 Clinton Place j S.F. 1922 C 735 Clinton Place Garage 1983 NC 736 Clinton Place S.F. 1924 + C 736 Clinton Place Garage 1924 C 737 Clinton Place S.F. 1919 N C 737 ) Clinton Place j Garage 1921 C 802 Clinton Place S.F. 1915 C 802 Clinton Place Garage 1921 C 803 Clinton Place S.F. 1919 N C 803 N Clinton Place Garage 1921 C 805 ' Clinton Place S.F. 1921 + C 805 Clinton Place Garage 1921 C 806 I Clinton Place S.F. 1920 C 806 Clinton Place Garage + 1923 C 810 Clinton Place S.F. 1921 C 810 Clinton Place Garage unk C 811 Clinton Place S.F. 1920 C 811 I Clinton Place Garage 1921 C 814 Clinton Place S.F. 1915 C N 814 Clinton Place Garage 1936 C I 815 Clinton Place S.F. 1920 I C 815 Clinton Place Garage unk C 818 I Clinton Place S.F. 1920 C Appendix B: Page 2 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 818 Clinton Place Garage 1921 C 819 Clinton Place S.F. 1916 C 819 Clinton Place Garage 1945 C 822 Clinton Place S.F. 1921 C 822 Clinton Place Garage unk C 823 Clinton Place S.F. 1920 C 823 Clinton Place Garaqe 1921 C 827 Clinton Place S.F. 1916 C 827 Clinton Place Garage 1928 C 831 Clinton Place S.F. 1921 C 831 Clinton Place Garage 1994 NC 619 Colfax Street S.F. (dorm) 1912 C 624 Colfax Street S.F. 1915 C 625 Colfax Street S.F. (office) 1910 C 628 Colfax Street S.F. 1916 C 628 Colfax Street Play House 1917 C 628 Colfax Street Garage unk NC 629 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 629 Colfax Street Garage 1962 NC 714 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 714 Colfax Street Garage mov. 1948 C 720 Colfax Street S.F. 1917 C 720 Colfax Street Garage 1973 NC 724 Colfax Street S.F. 1906 C 724 Colfax Street Garage 1925 C 725 Colfax Street Dormitory 1963 NC 728 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 728 Colfax Street Garage 1983 NC 732 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 732 Colfax Street Garage 1998 NC 735 Colfax Street S.F. 1935 C 802 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 802 Colfax Street Garage 1964 NC 805 Colfax Street S.F. 1916 C 806 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 806 Colfax Street Garage 1976 NC 807 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 807 Colfax Street Garage 1940 C 810 - Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 810 Colfax Street Shed 1928 C 811 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 811 Colfax Street Garage 1911 C 812 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 812 Colfax Street Garage 1912 C 815 Colfax Street S.F. 1907 C 815 Colfax Street Garage 1931 C 818 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 818 Colfax Street Garage 1910 C Appendix B: Page 3 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ • Other Non -Contributing 819 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 819 Colfax Street Garage 1921 C 822 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 822 Colfax Street Garage 1918 C 823 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 823 Colfax Street Barn 1908 C 827 Colfax Street S.F. 1911 C 827 Colfax Street Garage 1940 C 828 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 828 Colfax Street Garage 1911 C 900 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 900 Colfax Street Barn 1909 C 901 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 901 Colfax Street Garage 1990 NC 904 Colfax Street S.F. 1908 C 904 Colfax Street Barn 1909 C 905 Colfax Street S.F. 1910 C 905 Colfax Street Garaqe 1919 C 909 Colfax Street S.F. 1909 C 909 Colfax Street Garage 1923 C 911 Colfax Street S.F. 1939 C 618-24 Colfax Street S.F. 1915 C 618-24 Colfax Street Garaqe unk C 617 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1909 C 617 Dartmouth Place Garaqe unk C 620 Dartmouth Place Parking Lot NC 627 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1909 C 627 Dartmouth Place Garage 1915 C 630 Dartmouth Place S.F. (office) 1925 C 619 Emerson Street S.F. (office) 1922 C 633 Emerson Street Student Health Center 1960 NC 711 Emerson Street S.F. 1890 C 711 Emerson Street Garaqe unk C 717 Emerson Street Apt. 1964 NC 2700 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1937 C 2703 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1919 C 2703 Euclid Park Place Coach House 1919 C 2707 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1921 C 2707 Euclid Park Place Coach House 1921 C 2738 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1922 C 2738 Euclid Park Place Garaqe 1922 C 2746 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1922 C 2749 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1913 C 2749 Euclid Park Place Garage 1950 NC 2755 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1952 NC • 2755 Euclid Park Place Garaqe unk C 2756 Euclid Park Place S.F. 1918 C 2756 Euclid Park Place Garage unk C Appendix B: Page 4 Number Street Buildinq Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2765 I Euclid Park Place S.F. 1925 C 600 Foster Street Offices 1999 NC 617 Foster Street tudent Recreation Cente 1973 NC 629 Foster Street Religious Center 1999 NC 634 Foster Street S.F. 1870 C 709 Foster Street S.F. 1880 C 715 Foster Street S.F. 1911 C 714-16 Foster Street Apt. 1901 C 618 Garrett Place S.F. (office) 1914 C 618 Garrett Place Garage 1916 C 624 Garrett Place S.F. 1916 C 624 Garrett Place Garage 1924,1945 C 625 Garrett Place S.F. 1924 C 625 Garrett Place Garage 1940 C 628 Garrett Place S.F. 1912 C 628 Garrett Place Garage 1939 C 629 Garrett Place 2-Flat 1916 C 629 Garrett Place Garage 1917,1945 C 632 Garrett Place S.F. 1921 C 632 Garrett Place Garage 1987 NC 638 Garrett Place S.F. 1921 C 601-15 Garrett Place Student Apartments 1959 NC 621-23 Garrett Place Student Apartments 1961 NC 600 Haven Street fices, Library, Dormitory, 1929 C 600 Haven Street Wheeler Hall Addition 1955 NC 612 Haven Street Dormitory 1955 NC 617 Haven Street S.F. (office) 1911 C 625 Haven Street S.F. (office) 1914 C 625 Haven Street Garage 1919 C 629 Haven Street S.F. 1913 C 629 Haven Street Garage unk NC 638-40 Haven Street Double House 1963 NC 568 Ingleside Park S.F. 1967 NC 574 Ingleside Park S.F. 1950 NC 574 Ingleside Park Garage unk NC 574 Ingleside Park Garage unk NC 580 Ingleside Park S.F. 1959 NC 580 Ingleside Park Garage unk NC 581 Ingleside Park S.F. 1962 NC 586 Ingleside Park S.F. 1925 C 586 Ingleside Park Garage 1925 C 589 Ingleside Park S.F. 1956 NC 592 Ingleside Park S.F. 1893 C 592 Ingleside Park . Garage unk C 582 Ingleside Place S.F. 1907 C 585 Ingleside Place S.F. 1926 C 587 Ingleside Place S.F. 1998 NC 591 Ingleside Place S.F. 1998 NC Appendix B: Page 5 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 614 Ingleside Place S.F. 1920 C 614 Ingleside Place Garage unk C 621 Ingleside Place S.F. 1926 C 701 Ingleside Place S.F. 1960 NC 705 Ingleside Place S.F. 1954 NC 707 Ingleside Place S.F. 1998 NC 712 Ingleside Place S.F. 1920 C 713 Ingleside Place S.F. 1931 C 713 Ingleside Place Shed unk C 716 Ingleside Place S.F. 1922 C 720 Ingleside Place S.F. 1925 C 720 Ingleside Place Garage 1925 C 724 Ingleside Place S.F. 1921 C 724 Ingleside Place Garage 1921 C 730 Ingleside Place S.F. 1931 C 730 Ingleside Place Garage 1931 C 734 Ingleside Place S.F. 1997 NC 734 Ingleside Place Garage 1997 NC 802 Ingleside Place S.F. 1915 C 802 Ingleside Place Garage 1915 C 806 Ingleside Place S.F. 1914 C 806 Ingleside Place Garage 1917 C • 810 Ingleside Place S.F. 1916 C 810 Ingleside Place Garage unk C 814 Ingleside Place S.F. 1923 C 814 Ingleside Place Garage 1923 C 818 Ingleside Place S.F. 1919 C 818 Ingleside Place Garage 1919 C 823 Ingleside Place S.F. 1922 C 823 Ingleside Place Garage 1957 NC 824 Ingleside Place S.F. 1916 C 824 tngleside Place Garage unk C 828 Ingleside Place S.F. 1923 C 828 Ingleside Place Garage 1924 C 831 Ingleside Place S.F. 1921 C 831 Ingleside Place Garage 1921 C 832 Ingleside Place S.F. 1921 C 832 Ingleside Place Garage 1921 C 617 Library Place S.F. (office) 1894 C 618 Library Place Offices 1993 NC 619 Library Place 2-Flat 1915 C 619 Library Place Coach House 1917 C 620 Library Place S.F. (office) 1903 C 625 Library Place S.F. 1921 C 625 Library Place Garage 1966 NC • 626 Library Place S.F. (office) ' 1896 C 627 Library Place S.F. 1894 C 627 Library Place Garage 1937 C Appendix B: Page 6 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 628 Library Place Apt. 1971 NC 630 Library Place S.F. 1927 C 637-43 Library Place Apt. 1913 C 637-43 Library Place Garage 1929 C 640 Lincoln Street School 1915 C 711 Lincoln Street S.F. 1929 C 715 Lincoln Street S.F. 1914 C 715 Lincoln Street Garage unk NC 723 Lincoln Street 2-Flat 1915 C 723 Lincoln Street Garage unk C 727 Lincoln Street S.F. 1915 C 727 Lincoln Street Garage 1926 C 729 Lincoln Street S.F. 1914 C 729 Lincoln Street Shed unk C 731 Lincoln Street S.F. 1914 C 731 Lincoln Street Garage 1922 C 733 Lincoln Street S.F. 1912 C 733 Lincoln Street Garage 1912 C 800 Lincoln Street S.F. 1937 C 803 Lincoln Street 2-Flat 1915 C 803 Lincoln Street Garage 1979 NC 806 Lincoln Street S.F. 1926 C 806 Lincoln Street Garage 1926 C 807 Lincoln Street S.F. 1920 C 807 Lincoln Street Garage unk C 810 Lincoln Street S.F. 1926 C 810 Lincoln Street Garage 1926 C 811 Lincoln Street S.F. 1909 C 811 Lincoln Street Garage unk C 814 Lincoln Street S.F. 1925 C 815 Lincoln Street S.F. 1909 C 815 Lincoln Street Coach House unk C 818 Lincoln Street S.F. 1925 C 818 Lincoln Street Garage 1994 NC 819 Lincoln Street S.F. 1910 C 819 Lincoln Street Garage 1967 NC 822 Lincoln Street S.F. 1925 C 822 Lincoln Street Garage 1953 NC 825 Lincoln Street S.F. 1914 C 825 Lincoln Street Garage 1991 NC 826 Lincoln Street S.F. 1925 C 826 Lincoln Street Garage 1958 NC 827 Lincoln Street S.F. 1909 C 827 Lincoln Street Garage 1921 C 830 Lincoln Street S.F. 1925 C 833 Lincoln Street S.F. 1914 C 833 Lincoln Street Garage 1937 C 834 Lincoln Street S.F. 1931 C Appendix B: Page 7 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 834 Lincoln Street Garage 1931 C 837 Lincoln Street S.F. bef.1915 NC 837 Lincoln Street Garage unk NC 839 Lincoln Street S.F. 1927 C 840 Lincoln Street S.F. 1931 C 840 Lincoln Street Garaqe 1931 C 900 Lincoln Street S.F. 1935 C 902 Lincoln Street S.F. 1935 C 902 Lincoln Street Garage 1950 NC 905 Lincoln Street Park C 555-59 Lincoln Street Water Works 1874 C 1 Milburn Park S.F. 1954 NC 2 Milburn Park S.F. 1937 C 4 Milburn Park S.F. 1938 C 5 Milburn Park S.F. 1954 NC 5 Milburn Park Coach House 1954 NC 6 Milburn Park S.F. 1946 C 7 Milburn Park S.F. 1937 C 8 Milburn Park S.F. 1937 C 10 Milburn Park S.F. 1939 C 11 Milburn Park S.F. 1939 C 12 Milburn Park S.F. 1937 C 611 Milburn Street S.F. 1954 NC 617 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 617 Milburn Street Garage unk NC 623 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 623 Milburn Street Garage 1912 C 625 Milburn Street S.F. 1908 C 625 Milburn Street Garaqe 1961 NC 625 Milburn Street Garage unk C 631 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 631 Milburn Street Garape 1923 C 635 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 635 Milburn Street Garape unk NC 705 Milburn Street S.F. 1924 C 708 Milburn Street S.F. 1926 C 708 Milburn Street I Plav House 1969 NC 714 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 714 Milburn Street I Garape 1934 C 715 Milburn Street I S.F. 1924 C 715 Milburn Street Garage 1924 C 719 Milburn Street I S.F. 1923 C 719 Milburn Street Garage unk C 720 Milburn Street S.F. 1909 C 720 Milburn Street Garage 1923 C 725 Milburn Street S.F. 1921 C 725 Milburn Street I Garape unk NC 726 Milburn Street I S.F. 1911 C • W • Appendix B: Page 8 Number 0 Street N 726 729 729 730 730 733 734 734 739 803 803 806 806 807 807 810 810 811 811 815 816 816 819 820 820 821 821 822 822 824 824 825 825 826 826 830 830 831 831 835 835 836 839 839 840 715 715 719 Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Milburn Street Monticello Place Monticello Place Monticello Place Building Type Single Family/ Other Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garaqe S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. Barn S.F. Garage S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. S.F. Garage S.F. Date 1917 1923 1956 1907 1928 1930 1911 1917 1930 1910 unk 1910 1927 1922 1934 1910 1916 1924 1924 1917 1911 1916 1926 1910 1962 1922 1937 1913 1915 1910 1915 1921 1921 1915 1923 1910 1910 1860 1927 1922 1925 1958 1922 1975 1958 1914 1924 1924 Status Contributing/ .. Non -Contributing C C NC C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C NC C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C NC C NC NC C C C Appendix B: Page 9 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 719 Monticello Place Garage 1924 C 723 Monticello Place S.F. 1923 C 723 Monticello Place Garage 1923 C 727 Monticello Place S.F. 1927 C 731 Monticello Place S.F. 1915 C 731 Monticello Place Garage 1993 NC 734 Monticello Place S.F. 1920 C 735 Monticello Place S.F. 1915 C 735 Monticello Place Garage 1991 NC 800 Monticello Place S.F. 1923 C 800 Monticello Place Garage unk NC 803 Monticello Place S.F. 1914 C 806 Monticello Place S.F. 1922 C 806 Monticello Place Garage 1927 C 807 Monticello Place S.F. 1915 C 807 Monticello Place Garage 1947 C 809 Monticello Place S.F. 1916 C 809 Monticello Place Garage 1917 C 810 Monticello Place S.F. 1914 C 810 Monticello Place Garage 1914 C 811 Monticello Place S.F. 1915 C 811 Monticello Place Garage 1915 C • 812 Monticello Place S.F. 1919 C 812 Monticello Place Garage 1920 C 816 Monticello Place S.F. 1920 C 817 Monticello Place S.F. 1950 NC 817 Monticello Place Garage 1950 NC 817 Monticello Place Pavilion unk NC 822 Monticello Place S.F. 1915 C 822 Monticello Place Garage 1927 C 823 Monticello Place S.F. 1916 C 823 Monticello Place Garage 1983 NC 824 Monticello Place S.F. 1916 C 824 Monticello Place Garage 1972 NC 827 Monticello Place S.F. 1952 NC 830 Monticello Place S.F. 1922 C 616 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1900 C 617 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1912 C 617 Noyes Street Garage 1927 C 624 Noyes Street S.F. 1902 C 624 Noyes Street Garage 1945 C 625 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1898 C 629 Noyes Street S.F. (office) 1912 C 719 Noyes Street S.F. 1898 C 719 Noyes Street Garage 1911 C 725 Noyes Street S.F. 1898 C 725 Noyes Street Garage 1926 C 718-34 Noyes Street Co-op Apt. 1927 C Appendix B: Page 10 umber Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 1900 Orrington Avenue Apt. 1914 C 1906 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1875 C 1906 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1967 NC 1910 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1906 C 1910 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 1914 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1914 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 1915 Orrington Avenue 2-Flat 1916 C 1918 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1918 Orrington Avenue Garage 1916 C 1922 Ornngton Avenue S.F. 1896 C 1922 Orrington Avenue Barn unk C 1926 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1926 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk NC 1927 Orrinqton Avenue Dormitory 1970 NC 1930 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1930 Orrington Avenue Garage 1921 C 1934 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 1934 Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C 1936 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1894 C 1936 1940 Orrington Avenue Orrington Avenue Garage S.F. 1924 1895 C C 1940 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 1941 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1941 C 1942 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1942 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 1945 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1955 NC 1946 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 1946 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2001 Orrington Avenue Double House 1892 C 2005 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2005 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2010 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2010 Orrington Avenue Garage 1936 C 2011 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2011 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2014 Orrington Avenue 2-Flat 1903,1960s NC 2015 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1910 C 2015 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1910 C 2018 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2018 Orrington Avenue Garage 1920 C 2019 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2019 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2020 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1885 C 2020 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2023 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1978 NC 2023 Orrington Avenue Garage 1978 NC 2024 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1880 C Appendix B: Page 11 Number Street Building Type Date Status • Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2026 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1903 C 2026 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2027 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1875 C 2027 Orrington Avenue Garage 1997 NC 2030 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1903 C 2030 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2032 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2034 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk NC 2036 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2036 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2036 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2039 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2039 Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2040 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2040 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk C 2043 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1928 C 2043 Orrington Avenue Garage 1928 C 2047 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1928 C 2047 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1928 C 2102 Orrington Avenue I S.F. 1890 C 2102 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2103 Orrington Avenue I S.F. 1895 C • 2103 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1924 C 2106 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2106 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1924 C 2110 Orrington Avenue S.F. I 1898 C 2110 Orrington Avenue Garage 1985 NC 2111 Orrington Avenue S.F. I 1921 NC 2112 Orrington Avenue S.F. I 1893 C 2112 Orrington Avenue I Garage 1990 NC 2112 1 Orrington Avenue I Garage I unk C 2118 j Orrington Avenue S.F. I 1899 C 2118 Orrington Avenue I Garage 1918 C 2118 ( Orrington Avenue I Garage unk NC 2121 I Orrington Avenue I S.F. I 1909 C 2121 I Orrington Avenue I Garage 1922 C 2122 I Orrington Avenue I S.F. 1909 C 2122 I Orrington Avenue Garage I 1922 C 2126 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1890 C 2126 I Orrington Avenue Garage I 1953 NC 2127 Orrington Avenue I S.F. 1903 C 2127 I Orrington Avenue Garage I 1966 NC 2130 I Orrington Avenue I S.F. I 1915 C 2130 I Orrington Avenue I Garage unk NC 2131 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1965 NC 2131 I Orrington Avenue Garage 1966 NC 2134 I Orrington Avenue I S.F. 1911 C 2134 I Orrington Avenue ( Garage 1972 NC Appendix B: Page 12 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ I Other Non -Contributing 2135 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1902 C 2135 1 Orrington Avenue Garage 1913 C 2138 Orrington Avenue Garage 1920 C 2138 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2145 Orrington Avenue Double House 1963 NC 2146 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1912 C 2146 Orrington Avenue Garage 1920 C 2203 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2203 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1979 NC 2204 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2204 Orrington Avenue Garage 1904 C 2206 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1912 C 2206 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2207 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2207 Orrington Avenue Garage 1985 NC 2214 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2215 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2215 Orrington Avenue Garage 1969 NC 2218 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2219 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2219 -I Orrington Avenue Garage 1936 C 1&1 2222 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2233 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2233 ( Orrington Avenue Garage 1937 C 2236 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2236 Orrinqton Avenue Coach House 1906 C 2243 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1892 C 2243 Orrington Avenue Garage 1967 NC 2244 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1906 C 2244 Orrington Avenue Garage 1917 C 2246 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2246 I Orrington Avenue Garage 1917 C 2247 I Orrington Avenue Garage 1922 C 2247 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2252 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1914 C 2252 I Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2255 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2255 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2302 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2302 Orrington Avenue Garage 1927 C 2306 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1875 C 2306 I Orrinqton Avenue Coach House 1926 C 2306 I Orrington Avenue Garage 1993 NC 2307 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2307 Orrington Avenue Coach House 1917 C 2314 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1927 C 2315 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2315 I Orrington Avenue Garage 1924 C Appendix B: Page 13 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2316 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2316 Orrington Avenue Garage 1912 C 2316 Orrington Avenue Garaqe unk NC 2320 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2320 Orrington Avenue Garage 1998 NC 2323 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2323 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2326 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2326 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2330 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2330 Orrinqton Avenue Garage 1921 C 2331 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1919 C 2340 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2344 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2344 Orrington Avenue Garage 1919 C 2408 Orrington Avenue School 1907 C 2420 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1929 C 2424 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1929 C 2430 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1927 C 2430 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk C 2436 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2436 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2440 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2440 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2505 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1909 C 2510 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2511 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2511 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2515 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1908 C 2515 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 251-8 Orrington Avenue S:F. 1922 C 2518 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2519 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1914 C 2519 Orrington Avenue Garaqe unk C 2522 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2525 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1924 C 2525 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2529 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2529 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2600 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2608 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2614 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2614 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2618 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1925 C 2618 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2622 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2622 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2626 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1921 C 0.. • Appendix B: Page 14 41 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2626 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk NC 2636 Orrinqton Avenue School 1911 C 2637 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1924 C 2643 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1924 C 2645 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2645 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk C 2649 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2649 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk C 2653 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2653 Orrington Avenue Garage unk NC 2657 Orrington Avenue + S.F. 1920 C 2657 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2661 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1910 C 2662 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2665 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1910 C 2665 Orrinqton Avenue Garage unk C 2668 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1924 C 2669 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2672 Orrinqton Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2672 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2673 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2676 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1920 C 2677 I Orrington Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2677 Orrington Avenue Garage unk C 2680 Orrington Avenue S.F. 1920 C 2001-03 Orrington Avenue Garage 1925 C 2032-34 Orrington Avenue Double House N 1894 C 2437 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2437 Ridge Avenue Garage 1992 NC 2441 Ridge Avenue Garage 1945 C 2441 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1946 C 2505 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2505 I Ridge Avenue Garage unk C 2505 II Ridge Avenue Shed unk NC 2519 11 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1922 C 2519 II Ridge Avenue Garage unk I C 2535 II Ridge Avenue S.F. j 1940 C 2601 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1875 C 2601 Ridge Avenue + Garage 1971 NC 2607 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1910 C 2607 Ridge Avenue Garage 1988 N NC 2609 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2609 Ridge Avenue Garage 1954 NC 2615 Ridge Avenue S.F. j 1921 C 2619 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1880 C 2619 Ridge Avenue Garage 1928 ' C 2623 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1914 C 2623 Ridge Avenue Garage 1940 C Appendix B: Page 15 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2629 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2629 Ridge Avenue Garage 1927 C 2637 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1931 C 2705 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2705 Ridge Avenue Garage 1971 NC 2733 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2739 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1926 C 2739 Ridge Avenue Garage 1945 C 2743 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1924 C 2743 Ridge Avenue Garage 1990 NC 2747 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2747 Ridge Avenue Garage 1949 C 2751 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2751 Ridge Avenue Garage 1982 NC 2757 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1921 C 2757 Ridge Avenue Garage 1994 NC 2759 Ridge Avenue S.F. 1860 C 800 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1923 C 800 Ridge Terrace Garage unk C 801 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1925 C 802 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1923 C 802 Ridge Terrace Garage 1923 C 805 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1924 C 806 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1922 C 806 Ridge Terrace Garage 1923 C 809 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1924 C 810 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1927 C 810 Ridge Terrace Garage unk C 811 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1924 C 811 Ridge Terrace Garage 1924 C 814 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1921 NC 814 Ridge Terrace Garage 1926 C 815 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1915 C 815 Ridge Terrace Garage 1988 NC 816 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1922 C 820 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1921 C 820 Ridge Terrace Garage 1921 C 823 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1915 C 823 Ridge Terrace Garage 1923 C 824 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1916 C 824 Ridge Terrace Garage 1919 C 825 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1921 C 825 Ridge Terrace Garage 1921 C 829 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1915 C 829 Ridge Terrace Garage 1916 C 830 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1921 C 830 Ridge Terrace Garage 1925 C 832 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1922 C • Appendix B: Page 16 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributinq/ Other Non -Contributing 832 Ridge Terrace Garage unk NC 833 Ridge Terrace S.F. 1939 C 833 Ridge Terrace Garage 1939 C 2810 Sheridan Place S.F. 1960 NC 2829 Sheridan Place S.F. 1911 C 2831 Sheridan Place S.F. 1911 C 2837 Sheridan Place S.F. 1929 C 2837 Sheridan Place Coach House 1929 C 2841 Sheridan Place S.F. 1958 NC 2845 Sheridan Place S.F. 1910 C 2845 Sheridan Place Garage 1945 C 2848 Sheridan Place S.F. 1923 C 2848 Sheridan Place Garage 1923 C 2855 Sheridan Place S.F. 1911 C 2855 Sheridan Place Garaqe 1927 C 2856 Sheridan Place S.F. 1927 C 2856 Sheridan Place Garage 1927 C 2864 Sheridan Place S.F. 1919 C 2864 Sheridan Place Garage unk C 2865 Sheridan Place S.F. 1912 C 2865 I Sheridan Place Coach House 1915 C 2870 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1926 C 2877 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1967 NC 2878 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1915 C 2878 I Sheridan Place Garage 1933 C 2881 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1923 C 2888 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1926 C 2895 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1951 NC 2896 Sheridan Place S.F. 1954 NC 2800-08 I Sheridan Place S.F. 1914 C 2800-08 Sheridan Place Coach House unk C 1902 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1901 C 1908 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1892 C 1914 I Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1884 C 1918 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1922 C 1922 I Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1911 C 1936 I Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1893 ( C 1940 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1894 C 2000 I 'Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1921 C 2006 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) C 2010 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1917 C 2016 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1 1893 C 2036 I Sheridan Road Vacant Land C 2040 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1905 C 2040 I Sheridan Road Garage C 2044 Sheridan Road S.F. 1901 C 2044 Sheridan Road Garage C 2046 Sheridan Road S.F. (office) 1910 C Appendix B: Page 17 Number Street Buildinq Type Date Status • Single Family/ Contrbutinq/ Other Non -Contributing 2110 Sheridan Road Reliqious Center 1967 NC 2436 Sheridan Road Lonq Field C 2437 Sheridan Road S.F. 1916 C 2437 Sheridan Road Garaqe 1985 NC 2441 Sheridan Road Vacant Land C 2500 Sheridan Road S.F. 1959 NC 2510 Sheridan Road S.F. 1963 NC 2514 Sheridan Road S.F. 1909 C 2514 Sheridan Road Garage 1920 C 2520 Sheridan Road S.F. 1911 C 2520 Sheridan Road Garaqe 1927 C 2528 Sheridan Road S.F. 1911 C 2528 Sheridan Road Garage 1916 C 2535 Sheridan Road Light House 1873-74 C 2535 Sheridan Road Foq House 1873-74 C 2535 Sheridan Road Foq House 1873-74 C 2603 Sheridan Road S.F. (Art Center) 1927 C 2603 Sheridan Road Coach House 1927 C 2603 Sheridan Road Rest Rooms 1978 NC 2604 Sheridan Road S.F. 1955 NC 2615 Sheridan Road Picnic Shelter 1978 NC 2618 Sheridan Road S.F. 1954 NC • 2626 Sheridan Road S.F. 1954 NC 2645 Sheridan Road Park C 2651 Sheridan Road S.F. 1956 NC 2651 Sheridan Road Play House unk NC 2652 Sheridan Road S.F. 1954 NC 2652 Sheridan Road Garaqe unk NC 2652 Sheridan Road Pool House unk NC 2653 Sheridan Road S.F. 1979 NC 2655 Sheridan Road Coach House 1895 C 2655 Sheridan Road Garage unk NC 2658 Sheridan Road S.F. 1923 C 2658 Sheridan Road Coach House 1924 C 2664 Sheridan Road S.F. 1953 NC 2668 Sheridan Road S.F. 1953 NC 2674 + Sheridan Road S.F. 1925 C 2674 Sheridan Road Garage 1978 ' NC 2678 Sheridan Road S.F. 1924 C 2678 ( Sheridan Road Garaqe unk C 2681 Sheridan Road Garage 1907 C 2681 Sheridan Road S.F. 1892-93 C 2686 Sheridan Road S.F. 1927 C 2702 2702 I Sheridan Sheridan Road Road S.F. Garage 1912 unk C C 2714 j Sheridan Road S.F. 1926 C 2714 ( Sheridan Road Garaqe 1926 C 2715 Sheridan Road S.F. 1978 NC Appendix B: Page 18 Number Street Building Type Single Family/ Other 2717 Sheridan Road S.F. 2718 Sheridan Road S.F. 2718 Sheridan Road Garage 2719 Sheridan Road S.F. 2726 Sheridan Road S.F. 2726 Sheridan Road Coach House 2729 Sheridan Road S.F. 2730 Sheridan Road S.F. 2734 Sheridan Road S.F. 2734 Sheridan Road Garage 2735 Sheridan Road S.F. 2735 Sheridan Road Coach House 2737 Sheridan Road S.F. 2750 Sheridan Road S.F. 2754 Sheridan Road S.F. 2758 Sheridan Road S.F. 2767 Sheridan Road S.F. 2767 Sheridan Road Garage 2769 Sheridan Road S.F. 2769 Sheridan Road Garage 2770 2771 Sheridan Road Sheridan Road S.F. S.F. 2773 Sheridan Road S.F. 2775 Sheridan Road S.F. 2776 Sheridan Road S.F. 2780 Sheridan Road S.F. 2783 Sheridan Road S.F. 2784 Sheridan Road S.F. 2801 Sheridan Road S.F. 2815 Sheridan Road S.F. 2823 Sheridan Road S.F. 2039 Sherman Avenue 2-Flat 2043 Sherman Avenue S.F. 2107 Sherman Avenue Town House 2109 Sherman Avenue Town House 2111 Sherman Avenue Town House 2115 Sherman Avenue S.F. 2115 Sherman Avenue Garaqe 2115 I Sherman Avenue Garage 2119 I Sherman Avenue S.F. 2119 I Sherman Avenue Garage 2123 I Sherman Avenue S.F. 2123 Sherman Avenue Garage 2125 I Sherman Avenue S.F. 2125 Sherman Avenue Garage Sherman Avenue S.F. 72129 2129 I Sherman Avenue Garage 2131 Sherman Avenue S.F. Date Status Contributing/ Non -Contributing 1956 NC 1926 C 1926 NC 1909 C 1912 C 1915 C 1925 C 1923 C 1922 C 1922 C 1909 C unk C 1977 NC 1927 C 1922 C 1952 NC 1919 C 1922 C 1920 C 1927 C 1976 NC 1936 C 1974 NC 1954 NC 1977 NC 1928 C 1955 NC 1952 NC 1954 NC 1956 NC 1956 NC 1909 C 1894 C 1972 NC 1972 NC 1972 NC 1900 C unk I C unk I C 1895 I C unk N NC 1895 I C unk N NC 1895 I C unk I C 1896 C unk I C 1893 I C Appendix B: Page 19 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2131 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2135 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2135 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2137 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1894 C 2137 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2141 Sherman Avenue 2-Flat 1905 C 2141 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2145 Sherman Avenue 2-Flat 1905 C 2145 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2147 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2147 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2149 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2149 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2151 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1895 C 2151 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2201 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1915 C 2201 Sherman Avenue Garage 1920 C 2205 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1913 C 2205 Sherman Avenue Garage 1928 C 2207 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2207 Sherman Avenue Garage 1925 C 2211 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2211 Sherman Avenue Garage 1995 NC 2233 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2233 Sherman Avenue Garage 1997 NC 2235 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1899 C 2237 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1898 C 2237 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2241 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1905 C 2241 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2249 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1900 C 2249 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2253 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1901 C 2253 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2301 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1911 C 2301 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2305 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2305 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2309 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1904 C 2309 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2311 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1904 C 2311 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2315 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2315 Sherman Avenue Garage unk NC 2319 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1907 C 2319 Sherman Avenue Garage 1950 NC 2346 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1916 C 2346 Sherman Avenue Garage 1919 C • • n U Appendix B: Page 20 Number Street Building Type Date Status Single Family/ Contributing/ Other Non -Contributing 2351 Sherman Avenue S.F. (office) 1941 C 2433 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1911 C 2433 Sherman Avenue Garaqe 1963 NC 2434 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1915 C 2434 Sherman Avenue Garaqe unk NC 2436 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1915 C 2436 Sherman Avenue Garage unk C 2442 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2442 Sherman Avenue Garage 1945 C 2515 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1923 C 2519 Sherman Avenue S.F. 1923 C 718-24 Simpson Street Apt. 1909 C 721-31 Simpson Street Apt. 1916 C 968 968 • Appendix B: Page 21 APPENDIX C LIST OF DOCUMENTS IN THE RECORD Document Type or Title From Pages (+Attachments) Date Letter (and attachment) Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 2 (+1) 9/8/99 Letter Tom McMahon, ERP 3 9/13/99 Memo Tom and Ann McMahon 2 9/18/99 Letter (and copy of ERP letter) NEHDA 1 (+2) 9/19/99 Memo Tom McMahon 1 9/20/99 Letter re McMahon and ERP Robert Best 2 9/27/99 Letter re ERP Robert Best 1 9/27/99 Letter re Comprehensive General Plan Robert Best 6 10/8/99 Letter re Draft CGP Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 6 10/8/99 Historic District Nomination NEHDA, NNA„ STCA 10/19/99 Notice of Public Hearing Preservation Commission 2 10/28/99 Notification to Property Owners Preservation Commission 1(+2) 10/28/99 Certificate of Mailing Carlos D. Ruiz (Preservation Coordinat 1+ 10/29/00 Memo Judy Fiske, NEHDA 1(+1) 11/2/99 Letter Donald L. Schaffer 1 11/3/99 Memo to John Beischke (Evanston Revie Carlos D. Ruiz (Preservation Coordinat 1 11/9/99 Evanston Review (Notice of Public Hearir.Preservation Commission 1 11/11/99 Informational Public Meeting Preservation Commission 2(+1) 11/11/99 Memo Dewey Community Conference 2 11/15/99 OmLonv Jack Weiss 1 11/16/99 Eleanor White 1 11/16/99 Hearing Sign Up Sheet (In Support) 3 11/17/99+ Hearing Sign Up Sheet (In Opposition) 4 11/17/99+ Hearing Information Evanston Preservation Commission 2(+1) 11/17/99 Letter Ann Diener, Pres. League of Ev. 1 11/17/99 Testimony Polly Hawkins 3 11/17/99 Presentation to EPC Mary McWilliams 6 11/17/99 Testimony Patricia Money -Melvin 4 11/17/99 Testimony Mary Brugliera 1 11/17/99 Testimony Anne O. Earle 1 11/17/99 Memo Edwin R. Bates 1 11/17/99 Heating Transcript C. Thomas 145 11/17/99 Letter Astri L. Lindberg 1 11 /22/99 Letter Susan Solway, IHSAC 1 11/25/99 Letters (2) Save the Cottage Assoc. 2 11/29/99 Testimony (and attachments) Judy Fiske, NEHDA 4 (+2) 12/l/99 Testimony (and attachments) Mark Bumette, NEHDA 2 (+3) 12/1/99 Testimony Andrea & George Gaines 2 12/1/99 Testimony Jane & Howard Alt 1 12/l/99 Testimony Muffv Hendershot 2 12/1/99 Testimony Jim McGuire 2 12/1/99 Testimony (and attachment) Jeanne K Lindwall 3 (+1) 12/l/99 aring Transcript Denise Andras 123 12/l/99 stimony Barbara Mortensen 2 12/8 + 12/14/99 Memo (and slide presentation) Robert 1. Best 1 (+8) 12/2/99 Appendix C: Page 1 Document Type or Title From Pages (+Attachments) Date Testimony lane S. Smith 2 12/12/99 Statement Kay Gibbs-Novy & Stuart Now 1 12/14/99 Testimony Daniel Wefler 3 12/14/99 Testimony Marjorie & Charles Benton 1 12/14/99 Hearing Transcript Denise Andras 126 12/14/99 Testimony John Saliba 1 12/14/99 Letter Robert J. Best 2 12/16/99 Letter Richard F. Friedman 2 12/22/99 Memo C. R. Trieschman 4 1/7/00 Testimony Paul Stringer 1 1/12/00 Letter Janice Sachen 1 1/12/00 Testimony (criteria for district designation Brad White 6 (+5) 1/13/00 "Criteria for designation" (resume, excerpt Brad White 6 (+2,3) 1/13/00 Memo and articles on ranch houses Mary McWilliams 1 (+5) 1/13/00 "Why 2044 Sheridan Rd and other bldgs... Mary McWilliams 1 (+24) 1/13/00 Memo about Dr. C.W. Westfall Mary McWilliams 1/13/00 Testimony Margarita Matlis 2 1/13/00 Testimony Melinda Pierce 3 1/13/00 Letter Eugene S. Sunshine, NU Senior V. P. 6 1/13/00 Written Statement Regarding Evanston Pr Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 1(+51) 1/13/00 Testimony Arnold Lau & Ruby Bullen 2 1/13/00 Testimony Bonnie K WeIIer 1 1/13/00 Testimony Robert E. Janes 2 1/13/00 Testimony Melinda Pierce Testimony Rachel E. Golden 3 2 1/13/00 1/13/00 • Testimony (and excerpt from Comp Plan) Tom McMahon 2 (+15) 1/13/00 Testimony Barbara Mortensen 1 1/13/00 Letter (comments on NEHD, Westfall CV'Northwestern University 6 (+38,16) 1/13/00 Hearing Transcript Denise Andras 117 1/13/00 Letter Robert F. Perille 1 1/19/00 Letter William and Rachel Galer 1 1/20/00 Memo C. R. Trieschman 1 1 /25/00 Memo about Dr. Westfall's commentary Brad White 2 1/26/00 Memo William O'Neil & Rosemary O'Neal 1 1/26/00 Directory of Petitions Against the Local N Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 6(+3)+ 1/26/00 Written Statement Summarizing Presenta6Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 15 1/26/00 Hearing Transcript Denise Andras 107 1/26/00 Testimony Dewey Community Conference 2 1/27/00 Memo (Response to Submission from Not Brad White 2 1/27/00 Letter Brad White 2 1 /28/00 Letter to C.R. Trieschman J- Kirk Irwin 1 1 /28/00 Letter Alfred & Nancy Allred 1 1/31/00 Testimony Paula Twilling & David Cherry 1 1 /31 /00 Agenda EPC Meeting Preservation Commission 1 2/l/00 Letter (Response to Petitions Submitted in Judy Fiske, NEHDA 3(+77) 2/1/00 Letter (Descriptions of Historic Districts i Judy Fiske, NEHDA 1(+21) 2/1/00 Memo (Written Statement Regarding Evan -Mary McWilliams 3 2/l/00 Memo (District Size) Jean Kamps Lindwall (NEHDA) 2 2/l/00 • Letter (and petition, Pres. Ord. excerpt, E Bradford White & Raymond Tatum 4 (+11) 2/1/00 Directory of Petitions Against the Local N Evanstonians for Responsible Preserva 9 2/l/00 Memo Mike Ward, IHPA 1 2/1/00 Appendix Q Page 2 Document Type or Title From Panes (+Attachments) Date r (remarks by Westfall, plat survey, re Northwestern Universitv 2 (+8) 2/1/00 e _beration Transcripts Denise Andras 180 2/1/00 Letter (via fax) Robert Best 2 2/2/00 Fax Letter Ann K Adams 1 2/2/00 Letter ludv Fiske, NEHDA 1 2/3/00 Letter 1. Kirk Irwin 1 2/3/00 Deliberation Transcripts Denise Andres 27 2/8/00 Preservation Commission Special Meeting Bernadette Haupt 10 3/6/00 Resolution Preservation Commission 3 3/6/00 Certificate of Mailing Carlos D. Ruiz (Preservation Coordinal 1+ 3/10/00 Information Sheet Evanston Preservation Commission 4 no date shown "Remuddlins ' (photos and text) Tames D. McWilliams 22 no date shown "Criteria for determining critical features i Mary McWilliams 5 no date shown Memo Sarosh Saher, urban design spec. 3 no date shown Text from slide presentation (and attachm Jackie McGuire 4 (+2) no date shown Pictures Northwestern Neighbors -Jackie McGurn 16 no date shown Pictures (Chicago Historic District) NEHDA 8 no date shown Pictures (Northeast Evanston Local Histo NEHDA 13 no date shown Testimony lean Nerenberg 1 no date shown "Three secrets for retaining high -quality st James D. McWilliams 1 no date shown Testimony Susan Laws 1 no date shown "Response to submission, from Northwest Ravmond T. Tatum 10 (+6) no date shown Testimony Ann McMahon 9 no date shown List of ERP members Evanston for Responsible Preservatio 2 no date shown *e Exhibits (not identified) no date shown bit (Zoning Ordinance excerpt) William O'Neil 3 no date shown Testimony Daniel Schwartz 5 no date shown Testimony David Cella 2 no date shown Testimony Ruth Ann Hladish 1 no date shown Statement Sara Webb Phillips 1 no date shown Testimony Ruth Winter 1 no date shown Testimony Frank Steinberg 1 no date shown Testimony (and Ev Preservation Plan excerpt) 1 (+4) no date shown • Appendix C: Page 3